News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by ben7799 on Monday August 19, 2019 @10:13AM (#20737890)
I keep thinking I see this on my wired (Comcast) connection too.

Stuff just behaves too strangely for it to be anything else.

One video provider will get slow. Switch to the mobile connection and it's fine. Switch to another site on the wired connection, that's fine too.

They've made it perfectly clear they're unhappy I won't pay them an extra $100+/month for 900 channels of crap over and over.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jedberg on Monday August 19, 2019 @11:14AM (#20738464)
This is your ISP being sneaky, but probably not in the way you think. This is what Netflix has been complaining about for years.

Your ISP is purposely providing a too-small link to your video provider. So when a lot of people are using that provider, it gets slow. When you switch to another provider, or a VPN, you get to use a fast connection to that other VPN that isn't overloaded, and then a fast connection back to your video provider.

This way your ISP can claim they are not throttling traffic because they aren't inspecting the packets for traffic shaping, they are just using physically poor connectivity to certain providers for traffic shaping.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by briffle on Monday August 19, 2019 @11:22AM (#20738537)
Not to mention, they can now go and ask that provider to pay them for the right to 'upgrade' their connection, to enable their customers to get what they are paying the ISP for.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jedberg on Monday August 19, 2019 @11:31AM (#20738627)
Yup, and in Comcast's case, when Netflix finally paid Comcast's ransom, the problem was suddenly fixed a few minutes later, because Comcast literally just had to reconfigure the router and plug in a second cable.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jerkstate on Monday August 19, 2019 @12:26PM (#20739178)
In those days it was typical for the costs of peering to be borne by the sender, relative to the traffic ratio. This changed when Netflix and Youtube decided to use their PR and lobbying strength to bring the negotiation to the court of public opinion - and normal people started referring to typical peering cost-sharing agreements using emotionally loaded words like "ransom"
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by FireBeyond on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:19PM (#20740257)
Okay, let's go the other route then. BackBlaze, CrashPlan. These are companies where Comcast/other ISP customers are sending THEM huge amounts of data and getting nearly nothing in return.

So these ISPs should be bearing the costs of peering to backup providers, correct, by your logic? Or would that be the backup providers holding ISPs to "ransom"?

Apropos of anything else, ISPs (generally) provide massively asymmetric pipes. You can't provide an asymmetric pipe and then complain that data use on that pipe is, well, asymmetric.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by xorcist on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:12PM (#20741361)
Certainly your ingress/egress ratio affects what kind of peering deals you can get. Peering can be something of a wild west. If you can charge the other party, you do. Otherwise you don't.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jedberg on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:01PM (#20739483)
The ratio requirements are a red herring. If your ISP says you get a certain bandwidth, it is on them to provide the appropriate pipes to get to where their customers want to go. How can the ISP on the other side of Comcast be responsible for maintaining ratios if Comcast's customers are the ones that are requesting the data?
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by wang_li on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:25PM (#20739714)
>appropriate pipes to get to where their customers want to go.

This idea is nonsensical. What if I want to go to somewhere that is three times removed from my ISP. Comcast has zero capability to force some South Korean ISP that is providing services to some website to increase their bandwidth with their upstream who is peered with whoever owns the undersea cable that is peered with the company that peers with Comcast.

The alternative is that Netflix asks for 40 Gbps to Comcast and suddenly Comcast is obligated to provide 40 Gbps to every one of its customers.

What we've always gotten with an ISP is a given link rate to our ISP. Beyond that it's always been a crap shoot.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jedberg on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:02PM (#20741802)
If everyone up to the network edge is willing to pay for the equipment to get the packets there, and your customers are asking for the data, then yes, you have an obligation to deliver what you promised to your customer.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by wang_li on Monday August 19, 2019 @09:50PM (#20743220)
They promised X mbps between the customer and the customer's provider's network.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by criddell on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:08PM (#20739557)
So if Netflix were sitting on the end of a lowly T1, Comcast should provide Netflix with a more appropriate connection that can fulfill the demands of Comcast customers?
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jedberg on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:15PM (#20739614)
That's not a fair analogy. Netflix had the bandwidth available and wanted to connect it, Comcast just refused.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by criddell on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:26PM (#20739721)
At the time, Netflix didn't have a deal with Comcast. There was a company between the two (Cogent?) that wasn't purchasing enough bandwidth for what they were selling. If you were on Comcast and watched Netflix via an Apple TV, it worked fine because for some reason Apple TV streams were sent via Level 3.

The end result was Netflix doing a deal to connect directly with Comcast, cutting out the middleman (IIRC).

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by rhino369 on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:16PM (#20740853)
That's not really accurate either. Netflix's ISP didn't have the bandwidth available. That was the whole dispute. Their ISP wanted a free peering agreement and Comcast just refused.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by criddell on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:33PM (#20742014)
Netflix bought bandwidth from more than one company. That's why if you used a VPN or a different type of device for streaming, it would work. Comcast wasn't throttling Netflix in general, they had an oversubscribed link with Cogent.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jerkstate on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:04PM (#20739519)
How can Netflix claim to sell streaming video without paying for adequate bandwidth to stream that video?
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jedberg on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:15PM (#20739618)
They had sufficient bandwidth. Netflix paid their ISP for sufficient bandwidth. Comcast just refused to connect to it, to the detriment of Comcast's customers.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jerkstate on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:41PM (#20739882)
Cogent (Netflix's ISP) and Comcast had a peering agreement which spelled out costs and ratios; Cogent sold Netflix bandwidth (probably very cheaply) that they could not provide without breaching their peering agreement. Cogent was unwilling to fulfill the financial terms of their peering agreement in order to provide the product that they had sold to Netflix. Somehow, people think this is Comcast's fault?
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by liability on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:05PM (#20740129)
Netflix is a very popular company and Comcast is a deeply unpopular company. Consequently people take Netflix's statements at face value while assuming that Comcast always lies, even in situations where the facts suggest otherwise.

But who's fault is any of this? I say you reap what you sow. Comcast has only themselves to blame when consumers are skeptical of them.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by gog on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:59PM (#20742216)
You can also turn that statement around. Customers have paid Comcast to access the internet (Netflix) and Comcast didn't want to upgrade his peering with backbone providers forcing Netflix to pay them interconnection.

In this case Comcast is getting money from it's customers and then Netflix has to pay extra for the traffic Comcast's customers requested and paid for.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by sixothree on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:40PM (#20739865)
Aren't comcast subscribers limited in bandwidth based on the rate they pay?
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by ummonk on Monday August 19, 2019 @12:56PM (#20739434)
Netflix provides boxes it can plugin to local exchange points so all the ISP has to do is carry the last mile. How is that not sender pays?
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jessaustin on Monday August 19, 2019 @06:51PM (#20742504)
...the costs of peering to be borne by the sender, relative to the traffic ratio.

This "rule" is too simple to game, to have ever been a functioning rule. Netflix could have just patched their app to constantly upload lots of random data. This would have killed ISPs who often expect mostly-down traffic profiles, but it would have evened out "the ratio" so it theoretically would have won the peering argument. Of course, Netflix never did this, which proves that this so-called rule never really governed anything.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by hinkley on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:29PM (#20740364)
One of my biggest factors for choosing an ISP and contract is how much bandwidth streaming a high-res movie is going to take.

I had to chose Comcast when I moved because the alternative could only handle HD streaming but not 4K. And then I'm paying half again as much to be able to watch a pretty movie while others are using the internet, or for several of us to watch shows on our own.

Comcast is getting paid for bandwidth, plenty.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by briffle on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:41PM (#20739885)
Peering ratio requirements are kind of a scapegoat. Especially in the case of an 'eyeball' network like Comcast. I have 250Mb down, and 10mb up. (I would love 50Mb up, I push a ton of docker images daily). Their circuits they sell their clients will only re-enforce those ratios.. (then again, if netflix was to partner with a bunch of backup providers, like Mozy, crashplan, backblaze, etc, to carry their backup traffic, that could get VERY interesting)

[0] https://drpeering.net/white-papers/The-Folly-Of-Peering-Rati...

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jrockway on Monday August 19, 2019 @12:31PM (#20739206)
Peering has traditionally been free.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jerkstate on Monday August 19, 2019 @12:37PM (#20739265)
Subject to ratio requirements. Go have a look at peeringdb - there is a field for "Ratio Requirement" and it is common for that field to be "Yes"
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jrockway on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:53PM (#20741195)
Yeah, but these consumer ISPs self-inflicted the ratio imbalance. They literally don't let their customers upload at the same speed they download at; of course their peering ratios are going to be imbalanced.

I checked several of the largest ASNs and several smaller NYC-area ISPs on peeringdb and they are all "No" to the ratio requirement. Google doesn't care. Amazon doesn't care. Cloudflare doesn't care. There's half the Internet.

Demanding money to peer with Netflix is just trying to charge customers twice because they can. It's not normal, conventional, or good for the Internet. Netflix might be able to pay, but will your startup be able to pay? Probably not. And that's not the future we want.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by vorpalhex on Monday August 19, 2019 @12:45PM (#20739337)
And if Netflix and Youtube were being charged the actual charge for a tech to walk down and plug in another cable or pop together another interconnect, that would be fine.

Instead companies like Comcast are seeking to make profit from this.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jerkstate on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:03PM (#20739512)
All of the companies involved are seeking to make a profit. For example, Netflix and Youtube are seeking to lower their cost of bandwidth, thus increasing their profits.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by checktheorder on Monday August 19, 2019 @10:34AM (#20738090)
Same phenomenon for me in southern Ontario. My ISP (Start.ca) is using Rogers' infrastructure. Evenings equal poor streaming video performance on all sites despite an otherwise-perfect connection. If I connect to a VPN, video performance mysteriously improves instantly.

If I were of a suspicious mind, I'd wonder if Rogers is pulling some backend shenanigans to discourage cord-cutting.

Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by jedberg on Monday August 19, 2019 @11:15AM (#20738475)
See my sibling comment for a possible explanation.
Re:Wireless Carrier Throttling of Online Video Is Pervasive:... by devoply on Monday August 19, 2019 @10:33AM (#20738072)
> They've made it perfectly clear they're unhappy I won't pay them an extra $100+/month for 900 channels of crap over and over.

CEO: You know how we solve this, offer them more channels at a premium price. Which will show them 1 or maybe 2 shows they want to see.