This is more about proving your status to employers and such. Border agents will, presumably, be able to see your status electronically through their own system.
However, like other countries that do not need a visa to visit the UK, border agents could still refuse entry if they believe (for example) you intend to seek work rather than just visit.
They said EU citizens in the UK are welcome to stay and EU tourists will be welcome without visas, which is common sense, really.
Therefore I don't see the need to scare everyone. There are not going to start denying entry to EU citizens.
And I write this as an EU citizen in the UK.
However, in many cases the panic already exists, in no small part because the people running the UK refuse to be held to their own previous promises, even when it comes to what they want from Brexit.
"If your application is successful, a letter will be emailed to you confirming your settled or pre-settled status. The letter you get from the Home Office which confirms your status will include a link to an online service. You can use this service to view and prove your status."