Re:Ask HN: What do you expect Hacker News to look like in 5 ...
by redthrowaway on Friday January 07, 2011 @02:41AM
(#2078961)
Would you ever consider implementing subreddits? The reddit team has said that they were implemented in order to help the site scale without losing the small community feel, and that certainly holds true for some of the smaller, more focused subreddits.
Alternatively, would you take steps to limit new membership? HN these days is often mentioned in the same breath as Twitter, Reddit, and Digg by many bloggers. I don't see that trend stopping any time soon, so if you didn't plan on implementing subreddits, then something like this might be necessary.
The Eternal September phenomenon has always been fascinating to me, not least because it is one of the Internet's oldest problems, yet it remains unsolved. I'd be interested in reading your thoughts on how a community can protect itself from dilution in this manner. Beyond the ideas expressed in the following link, did you have any other thoughts? Has anything changed your mind in the past year?
Re:Ask HN: What do you expect Hacker News to look like in 5 ...
by idheitmann on Tuesday January 11, 2011 @06:05PM
(#2094005)
If HN has jumped the shark, what's the next hip spot?
http://news.ycombinator.com/classic
As you can see, it's still not much different from the regular frontpage, which is encouraging.
The median comment is probably not as good as it was several years ago, nor as civil, but things aren't dramatically worse, partly because the sorting of comments (which I've tweaked a fair amount) means the lame ones are less visible.
HN traffic roughly doubles each year. That growth rate shows no sign of decreasing. If it continued we'd have 32x the traffic in 5 years. We currently get a bit over 80k unique visitors on a typical weekday. 32x that is 2.6 million. It seems overoptimistic to expect the site could grow to that size and still be bearable to use. So probably either the growth rate is going to have to decrease, or HN will be destroyed. I'll do my best to make sure it's not the latter.