Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s...
by hombre_fatal on Sunday August 18, 2019 @02:54PM
(#20732097)
> Native apps have pretty robust permissioning systems.
They really don't, though. No better than websites. I was astounded when I first used Little Snitch and saw how often random apps were making network requests. For example, Translate Tab (a simple language translation app) sends every translation to Google Analytics. And you need a relatively sophisticated tool / expertise just to see this.
It made me rethink the superiority of native apps since all this is so hidden. I prefer websites over native apps because I can run uBlock/uMatrix. Native apps can do whatever they want when it comes to tracking. People aren't even talking about it.
Not only do native apps get off scot free, HN glamorizes them as superior with no questions asked.
Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s...
by bluepnume on Sunday August 18, 2019 @03:56PM
(#20732434)
That's a fair point. I wonder if 'make network calls' was ever considered as an app permission, or if it was just considered so ubiquitous that it would be granted by default. Or if there was any thought made around 'same domain' and 'cross domain' restrictions for apps.
I wish the latest round of privacy restrictions (which I think are overall a decent idea) would take these use cases into account, or at least allow a mechanism to request the user's permission to use third party cookies for sites they trust.
Native apps have pretty robust permissioning systems. Why shouldn't websites?
(For context, these are some of the things we use at PayPal to build embeddable cross-domain components: https://medium.com/@bluepnume/introducing-paypals-open-sourc...)