News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by jraph on Sunday August 18, 2019 @05:24AM (#20729180)
Yeah I'm fed up with unwarranted mentions of Brave. Indeed they are always "aggressive, misleading, promotional", and nothing close to informational. The article was supposed to be about Apple and Webkit, and Brave is just off-topic.

Brave is not a privacy-focused browser. It is an ad-focused browser and the business model of Brave is just this: ads, through Basic Attention Tokens. Privacy and BATs are in conflict and Brave will never be incentivized to respect the privacy of all its users. If you want privacy for you and for everyone, competition except Chrome is already better.

Brave is not a solution for a browser user's problem.

Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by bad_user on Sunday August 18, 2019 @05:41AM (#20729239)
Competition that's preferably not based on Chromium, because Chromium's marketshare gives Google incredible leverage on the market. Witness how they are pushing AMP.

At this point there are only two browsers left: Firefox and Safari.

Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by SquareWheel on Sunday August 18, 2019 @06:24AM (#20729378)
AMP works in all browsers. It doesn't rely on anything Chromium-specific.
Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by vorticalbox on Sunday August 18, 2019 @07:18AM (#20729553)
It still lets one company set the standard for the web even if what they push does work on all browsers.
Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by akerl_ on Sunday August 18, 2019 @08:42AM (#20729843)
I’m not seeing the connection between Chromium and AMP.

AMP, for what it’s worth, is based on existing web standards. It’s a restrictive way of using those standards, but it sits on top of existing standard tech. And Google is using their position as a search engine to push that, not their position as a browser vendor (as evidenced by the fact that AMP has the same effect in Firefox/Safari as it does in Chrome).

Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by tim58 on Sunday August 18, 2019 @10:51AM (#20730460)
The connection is this: Google has a large amount of influence in the Chromium code base. Using Chromium, a codebase Google Controls, gives them addition leverage in controlling how the web is viewed and built.
Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by akerl_ on Sunday August 18, 2019 @03:39PM (#20732337)
I don’t think anybody is disputing that Google’s influence over Chromium gives them leverage over the browser space. This is evident in things like their changes to how TLS certificate metadata is displayed, support for TLS 1.3, and changes to how content is rendered.

But this comment thread includes the claim that their influence over Chromium is being used to push AMP, and I don’t see how they are using their position with Chromium to push AMP, a technology that uses a specific subset of existing web technology and operates cross-browser already.

Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by lern_too_spel on Sunday August 18, 2019 @10:52AM (#20730474)
The technical steering committee for AMP has members from multiple companies, with only a minority employed by Google.
Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by saagarjha on Sunday August 18, 2019 @01:25PM (#20731535)
Technically correct, but not useful. Three of the seven members of the committee are employed by Google, and the other four members are each from different companies: https://github.com/ampproject/meta-tsc#members. Plus, it's not clear wether each member has the same amount of "power".
Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by lern_too_spel on Sunday August 18, 2019 @02:15PM (#20731847)
> it's not clear wether each member has the same amount of "power".

Each member gets one vote. Membership to the group is decided by the group, with a goal of no more than 1/3 coming from one company. The distinction I pointed out is both technically and practically correct.

https://github.com/ampproject/meta/blob/master/GOVERNANCE.md

Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by onyva on Sunday August 18, 2019 @05:40AM (#20729236)
Just the newspeak idea alone of "Basic Attention Tokens" ... makes me think of the dystopic "Maniac" and AdBuddy.
Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by giancarlostoro on Sunday August 18, 2019 @09:23AM (#20729995)
Hate to say it but at least AdBuddy doesnt follow you around. They just share random ads.
Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by justsee on Sunday August 18, 2019 @09:19AM (#20729974)
There is always something curious about an opinion so strongly held and communicated that is at the same time so wilfully ignorant.

Brave is clearly a privacy-focused browser: it takes very little time for a technically-minded, veteran HNer to kick the tyres on that project's focus and codebase to understand that privacy is their USP.

It's obvious the whole team believes in the idea of a user agent being an Agent of the User.

A little more time reviewing key figures, from Yan Zhu through to Johnny Ryan, reveals the calibre and integrity of people working on this project.

They are attempting to build a model that upsets the current surveillance capitalism status quo, so it's no surprise that there are attempts to spike perceptions around the project.

Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by onyva on Sunday August 18, 2019 @05:48PM (#20733142)
ROFL. Especially the “a user agent being an agent of the user”. Who said surveillance capitalism has no sense of humor ...?
Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by justsee on Sunday August 18, 2019 @06:11PM (#20733259)
Browsers can and should be agents of the user: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_agent

Google's Chrome has distorted that historical idea so they are agents of the ad network and advertiser, working against the user.

Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by onyva on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:51AM (#20735217)
No sure. I get it. But the seriousness with which you attribute a for profit like brave a benevolent mission, as if. How many times do we need to go down the same road of talking about features vs what really counts: track record and who's actually standing behind the technology? Clue: people. Why would you trust Brave to begin with? Because Brenden Eich is such a role model (a racist homophobe last time I checked)?
Re:Apple will soon treat online web tracking the same as a s... by BrendanEich on Sunday August 25, 2019 @09:17AM (#20792783)
You checked and found I am racist? Where?

As for homophobe, I reject your definition. Call me what you want there, but “racist” is a lie. Either yours or your “last I checked” source’s.

From what you write, nonprofits are innocent and for-profits are guilty. I worked for a nonprofit or its wholly owned for-profit subsidiary for 11 years, and I can tell you that the profit motive does not go away in nonprofits. Check the 2017 form 990 on Mozilla’s site for the top salary, >$2.3m. I never got 1/3rd that and went down to 1/15th to start Brave.

Brave uses all open source for auditability and we pay for audits as well as bug bounties. We pay the user 70% of user private ad revenue. For publisher ads (not yet done, working with publisher partners) we will pay users the same 15% we get - publisher gets 70%. So we won’t make revenue without our users being happy and making more than we make. Let’s see Firefox share Google search revenue (which held up tracking protection in Firefox for years) with its users, giving more to the user than Mozilla gets.

You ad hominem argument against an open source product is absurd on its face. Should right wingers use only software from righties? How many tribes must hive off and build their own software, and reject open source that’s ritually unclean? Judge products on their observable design, implementation, and business properties.