News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fact and folklore in software engineering by gacba on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @03:35PM (#2072356)
I would love to know how a study could be conducted in such a way to prove or disprove this notion. Any ideas? Any existing data sets that could reliably mined for info?
Re:Fact and folklore in software engineering by Morendil on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @03:49PM (#2072422)
I wouldn't start with a data set. I would start by stating clearly enough the question we are looking for an answer to.

Doing that might involve getting clear on the terms. "Productivity" is too abstract and ambiguous to be used as-is, so we first need to say "here is what we are going to measure".

Re:Fact and folklore in software engineering by narag on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @05:57PM (#2072934)
I believe that what people try to determine is not a very precise measure of productivity, but the fact that productivity measurement doesn't matter so much.

The central message that I remember from Peopleware is that software teams are more about people than about numbers.

Performance is going to vary, often wildly (often for the same people at different times). I loved the anecdote of the woman that wasn't very productive herself, but was a "catalyst", maybe simply a fancy way to say she was fun and nice to work with.

Unless you are Google and have the right process to detect the best and resources to attract them, your best bet is to treat people well and apply common sense... as opposed to apply hard metrics and put pressure, demoralizing your people.

Re:Fact and folklore in software engineering by kenjackson on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @04:12PM (#2072490)
Bingo. Software engineering is filled with throwing about this term "productivity" yet its unclear as to what it means. And even what the impact is.

With that said, this is not trivial even for activities where the metrics seem a lot clearer, e.g., basketball or basetball.

Re:Fact and folklore in software engineering by daviding on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @04:16PM (#2072503)
Re:Fact and folklore in software engineering by stonemetal on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @04:48PM (#2072653)
First you would have to define what you are measuring and develop the experiment. Then get enough HN readers to sign up to take the experiment so that you get statistically significant results.

For caned results that you could look at I would think ICFP programming contest or similar would have numbers though a quick look hasn't turned anything up.