News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slate sticker shock: Asus Windows 7 tablet priced at $999 by randallsquared on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @03:24PM (#2072327)
Er, the stylus thing is not entirely off the mark. My N900 has a stylus, and there are programs I cannot use without it (notably, the web browser is nigh useless without it, since text that's perfectly comfortable for reading means links that are way too small to hit reliably with a finger). So, a stylus actually can be a point in its favor.
Re:Slate sticker shock: Asus Windows 7 tablet priced at $999 by roc on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @03:38PM (#2072371)
Another way to look at that state of affairs is: the required stylus is a point against the n900's browser.

Styluses, particularly for navigation, have been rejected by the market. So relying upon them is simply a bad idea if you dare to dream of outperforming anything in the graveyard of Windows-Tablets-Past.

Re:Slate sticker shock: Asus Windows 7 tablet priced at $999 by jsnell on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @04:22PM (#2072532)
I've got small hands, and really hated using the browser on an iPhone due to how easy it was to click the wrong link by mistake on any sites that don't have an separate version optimized for mobiles. Switching to a Nexus 1 from an iPhone 3G was worth it just for the trackball. Unfortunately the Nexus S removed the trackball, making it a downgrade over the N1 as a whole :-(

It's a sad world when solving the problem counts as a black mark, while putting your hands over the ears and singing la-la-la-there is no problem counts as good user experience and paying attention to detail.

Re:Slate sticker shock: Asus Windows 7 tablet priced at $999 by roc on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @04:31PM (#2072577)
> "really hated using the browser on an iPhone due to how easy it was to click the wrong link by mistake"

You know you can zoom the page effortlessly and be sure the tap is properly placed amongst a group of links, right?

Re:Slate sticker shock: Asus Windows 7 tablet priced at $999 by bryanlarsen on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @05:13PM (#2072742)
Sure, I can zoom effortlessly, but it would be a lot easier if I didn't have to, since that also involves zooming back out and scrolling the page once you go back. 4 steps instead of 1.

Except when you zoom way in and still miss, because what you're clicking on is a javascript implicit trigger right beside an explicit link, so the browser tries to be helpful and assumes you really wanted the explicit link.

I used to browse on my N810 a lot, and now use a Nexus S or an iPhone. The switch to a capacitive screen had many benefits and was the right move, but I sometimes do miss the accuracy of the old resistive screens.

Re:Slate sticker shock: Asus Windows 7 tablet priced at $999 by roc on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @05:26PM (#2072804)
I used to browse on my n800 a lot. I now browse on my iPhone a lot more. Because the convenience, rendering, panning and zooming far, far outweigh the lost accuracy of the stylus.
Re:Slate sticker shock: Asus Windows 7 tablet priced at $999 by bryanlarsen on Thursday January 06, 2011 @11:20AM (#2075861)
Sure, but a large part of that is because the current generation of browsers on current hardware is a LOT faster. On the n810 you had hardware buttons to zoom, so it's not as if that was less convenient interface wise, it was inconvenient because it was slow.
Re:Slate sticker shock: Asus Windows 7 tablet priced at $999 by jsnell on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @05:36PM (#2072852)
Oh, sure. There's plenty of kludges that you can use to work around the inaccuracy of the finger + capacitative touchscreen combo. The problem with zooming is that you can't pinch-zoom with just one hand, and the doubletap-zoom sometimes wouldn't zoom in enough. Also it makes the workflow of the really simple operation that little bit more complicated: doubletap somewhere nearby, wait for the zoom, find the link again, tap.

As another example, in the Android browser a long press on a link will highlight the link after half a second, and pop up a menu after a second. So you can start pressing on the link, wait for it to get highlighted, and then quickly either "commit" by lifting the finger or "rollback" by dragging it away from the link.

Pretty horrible, right? But at least I occasionally find even that to be more convenient than zooming.

Re:Slate sticker shock: Asus Windows 7 tablet priced at $999 by regularfry on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @04:28PM (#2072564)
Market be damned. I like it.
Re:Slate sticker shock: Asus Windows 7 tablet priced at $999 by ugh on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @03:31PM (#2072350)
I think “requires” is the important word.