News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What3words divides the world into squares, each with a un... by mruts on Friday August 16, 2019 @03:38AM (#20712952)
Uhh, okay. This is already a solved problem, it’s called GPS. I can see this would be useful as an address system, but using it for the police to find you? Doesn’t make much sense.
Re:What3words divides the world into squares, each with a un... by Piskvorrr on Friday August 16, 2019 @03:49AM (#20712997)
This is based on GPS. The three words are a hash of the coordinates; this seems more user-friendly and less error-prone than "14.1234567,50.35466, wait, no, 50.53466, or is it -50.53466,14.1234567?".

As opposed to e.g. the Maidenhead locator, this has the properties of a hash - in other words, isn't trivially reversible, and you need the w3w company to provide you with the location, each and every time (jackpot!).

Re:What3words divides the world into squares, each with a un... by Freak_NL on Friday August 16, 2019 @03:53AM (#20713016)
> "14.1234567,50.35466, wait, no, 50.53466, or is it -50.53466,14.1234567?".

All of which are fine for someone lost in X mountain range. The operator on the other side will know whether -50.* or 14.* is latitude or longitude.

Also, you would just read the numbers from your screen, no ambiguity there.

Re:What3words divides the world into squares, each with a un... by Piskvorrr on Friday August 16, 2019 @03:58AM (#20713044)
Thank you, thank you. You have demonstrated the flaw perfectly: didn't even notice the swapped digits, which would send SAR to someplace plausible yet far away.
Re:What3words divides the world into squares, each with a un... by jjeaff on Friday August 16, 2019 @04:59AM (#20713351)
I'm at steeple, bound, force...

People? No steeple ... S as in Sam, steeple.

Was that mound or found?

B as in boy, o as in Oscar, u as in unit....

Ok, steeple, boy, Oscar...

There is a reason the military alphabet exists and all numbers are pronounced as is (except for the occasional Niner to avoid confusing nine with 5)

Re:What3words divides the world into squares, each with a un... by IshKebab on Friday August 16, 2019 @04:31AM (#20713217)
I'm pretty sure long-pressing your location in Google Maps and reading out two numbers is a fair bit easier than downloading a new app that you've never heard of.
Re:What3words divides the world into squares, each with a un... by Piskvorrr on Friday August 16, 2019 @04:45AM (#20713285)
Sure, network effect and all that. OTOH, I distinctly recall being told of a new search engine I've never heard of, I think it was called "Google". Everything was new and unknown once ;)
Re:What3words divides the world into squares, each with a un... by Piskvorrr on Friday August 16, 2019 @05:17AM (#20713437)
@IshKebab: Okay, I went ahead and tried. GMaps gives you both the GPS coordinates and the Open Location Code. That's significantly better than complaint above "it's popular because it's popular". Fair point.
Re:What3words divides the world into squares, each with a un... by julienreszka on Friday August 16, 2019 @03:52AM (#20713012)
It's faster to read than long lat and it probably uses gps. The innovation is in the user friendly hash table of Geo locations
Re:What3words divides the world into squares, each with a un... by pgeorgi on Friday August 16, 2019 @04:20AM (#20713151)
And apparently it has to feed 100 employees (what are they even doing?)

I doubt that's true for https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Location_Code and so I'd be less concerned about incentives changing over time (also, it doesn't need a central maintainer for the hash map).

Re:What3words divides the world into squares, each with a un... by jjeaff on Friday August 16, 2019 @05:01AM (#20713359)
3 employees to maintain the system. 97 employees doing sales, marketing, and PR.
Re:What3words divides the world into squares, each with a un... by julienreszka on Friday August 16, 2019 @05:56AM (#20713607)
Olc Isn't as user friendly as three words
Re:What3words divides the world into squares, each with a un... by pgeorgi on Friday August 16, 2019 @07:01AM (#20713893)
It's the same letters around the globe though.

If you have a bunch of folks exchanging the following 3 Word Addresses, you better hope they get it textual in a medium that allows copy & paste - in which case OLC is no worse off.

语焉不详.思潮.眼球 (962CWVRJ+9X)

ज्ञात.महाकाय.भौहों (9G4729FC+39)

(58H58WHV+GX) القول.تفريق.لأهتم

เคี้ยว.สมุนไพร.ผัก (9F4MG95X+7M)

штанишки.вытер.разбавлять (8GW3XJP2+RV)

And then there's terms of use:

- For 3 Word Addresses you (hopefully) get "a non-assignable, non-transferable, non-exclusive and revocable licence". (note: revocable)

- And worse, with the list above I might have violated their ToS: "Further, you must not publish (yourself or via a third party) any list or database of 3 Word Addresses with 3 Word Address Locations".

- It's also not allowed to provide a service that translates a 3 Word Address into something else (such as OLC or GPS coordinates) so they could be used with software or devices that happen to use different schemes: "you may use any 3 Word Address in any way that you wish, provided ... you in no way use 3 Word Addresses or 3 Word Address Locations to provide or seek to provide a product or service the same as or similar to any product or service provided by us"

- Finally, if they ever decide to shut down their server, all your 3 Word Address are gone as "any copying, re-utilisation, extraction, reproduction or redistribution of the what3words Materials ... is expressly prohibited".

Re:What3words divides the world into squares, each with a un... by j_4 on Friday August 16, 2019 @04:00AM (#20713058)
"You can build such a system quite trivially", etc. Turning a long numeric sequence into a memorable phrase easy to input with both text and speech solves a real problem.