News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lisp IDEs (where for art thou?) by xyzzyz on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @08:36AM (#2070892)
Funny how he does not even provide single reason, why he discards Emacs as a Lisp IDE.
Re:Lisp IDEs (where for art thou?) by amouat on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @09:19AM (#2071000)
Because I didn't want to start a religious debate about Emacs, which seems to have happened anyway ;)

Actually, I don't see why I have to defend this. I've used Emacs before, I don't really want to again. Isn't that good enough? I'm happy for everybody that gets along with Emacs, but I'd appreciate another choice.

Re:Lisp IDEs (where for art thou?) by brlewis on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @09:56AM (#2071129)
I don't see a single comment here on HN resembling religious debate. I see a lot of people wanting to help, but unable to unless you're specific about your problems with emacs. Emacs is the dominant IDE. All the alternatives have weaknesses. Which weaknesses are showstoppers for you, and which aren't?
Re:Lisp IDEs (where for art thou?) by Homunculiheaded on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @11:23AM (#2071394)
But for common lisp emacs+slime is the way to go. This is similar to writing .NET in anything but visual studio, or java without eclipse or intelliJ. Of course you can do these things, but it's very likely you'll find some frustration. Of course sometimes using your favorite tool is worth the frustation, sometimes it's not.

Ever since writing an application in Smalltalk (squeak) I've realize that a language and the environment it's edited in are very closely tied together. If 90% of the community of lispers uses Emacs+Slime there's probably a good reason. I don't particularly like Eclipse, but if I'm doing a reasonably large Java project I'll definitely be using it.

Re:Lisp IDEs (where for art thou?) by brlewis on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @08:58AM (#2070946)
Since he tried slimv first I assume he's a vim user. But if he's willing to try eclipse he should be willing to try emacs, at least with cua-mode: http://emacswiki.org/CuaMode

I left a comment to that effect.

Re:Lisp IDEs (where for art thou?) by ludwigvan on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @09:01AM (#2070950)
I inferred that he doesn;t want to spend time learning how to use Emacs, given Conrad "doesn't want to spend time explaining how to use Emacs".

Emacs is well worth the time, though; I agree with you.

Re:Lisp IDEs (where for art thou?) by amouat on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @09:29AM (#2071033)
No, I agree that Conrad shouldn't be teaching Emacs. He could have explained how to use any old text editor by loading from the REPL though.

I just don't want to learn Emacs. I just don't want to learn Emacs. I didn't think this was a controversial point. Why does learning lisp mean learning Emacs?

Re:Lisp IDEs (where for art thou?) by xyzzyz on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @09:47AM (#2071091)
Why does learning Lisp mean learning Emacs? Because it is the best available environment for Lisp, at least among free ones.

Mobody forces you to learn Emacs, but then you either have to pay for commercial IDEs, or use some unhelpful (even hostile, if you are used to benefits provided by sophisticated IDEs) enviroment. You can also set up Eclipse plugins which nobody in the Lisp world heard about, let alone uses. You can use simple text editor and go back to the way software was written in 70s. All these things because you refuse to use some piece of software, and yet are willing to learn others. The choice is yours, of course.

Re:Lisp IDEs (where for art thou?) by aerique on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @10:34AM (#2071249)
Are you the child of Erik Naggum's cat?
Re:Lisp IDEs (where for art thou?) by xyzzyz on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @11:10AM (#2071356)
Excuse me, what?
Re:Lisp IDEs (where for art thou?) by ludwigvan on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @09:47AM (#2071093)
OK, OK ;) Upvoted for repetition.