News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by ocdtrekkie on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:02PM (#20707144)
I think the ultimate problem is Google doesn't pay anyone. Google is the default winner in this scenario, they always list for free. Essentially creating a scenario where no matter who is chosen, Google wins. Either the user selects Google and Google makes money off of them, or they select Google's competitor and Google takes money from their competitors.

An auction is a fair way to determine a group of options, but an auction where one party always wins for free is not. The solution is to break up Google, and force Google to bid for the right to show up on the list on Android-the-company's platform just like everyone else.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:50PM (#20708971)
> The solution is to break up Google, and force Google to bid for the right to show up on the list on Android-the-company's platform just like everyone else.

Google already pays more to fund Android than it would cost to place in a search engine listing auction. If all you're really suggesting is that they do separate accounting for part of that funding and call it "large bid in search engine listing auction" then nothing changes in practice.

Which is kind of the point. They're already effectively paying for placement by funding Android development in general.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by sm4rk0 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @04:35PM (#20709370)
That would be fair enough if there wasn't a link (Google account) that connects me as an Android user with me as a Google search user. They even could be separate companies, but they would be still tracking me as one person and selling my data together. Please correct me if that would be legally impossible.
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by leereeves on Thursday August 15, 2019 @04:48PM (#20709497)
It may not change much now, while Google is dominant and profitable in both markets, but it would prevent using Android revenue to prop up search in the future, if say DuckDuckGo became the leading search engine.
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by onion2k on Friday August 16, 2019 @03:18AM (#20712862)
Google already pays more to fund Android than it would cost to place in a search engine listing auction.

Sounds like it'd be a win for Google as well then. Brilliant.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by ijpoijpoihpiuoh on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:07PM (#20707933)
If Android were a separate company from Google, and the owners of Android and Google were the same (i.e. the post anti-trust breakup scenario), you'd expect a financially equivalent outcome. Google will obviously bid high enough that they are going to end up in the choice screen. How do we know this? iOS.

As an owner, I don't care if one of my companies pays the other one some money. There are probably some accounting details, but ultimately it matters little. Other search engines would be competing for second, third, and fourth place.

The only material difference between the current scenario and that one is that, IRL, Google will continue sponsoring Android even if this auction were insufficient to keep it solvent on its own. Otherwise, the outcome is the same. Of course, in that imaginary world, Android probably would become insolvent at some point, because a free mobile OS is not exactly a big money maker. I wonder who would buy it? See, even that other world naturally tends to become this one.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by whalabi on Thursday August 15, 2019 @02:33PM (#20708210)
> [...] Android probably would become insolvent at some point, because a free mobile OS is not exactly a big money maker

They'd still be making 30% is it? On every app purchase and in-app purchase on the play store, which is surely in the billions.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by Buraksr on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:21PM (#20708710)
It seems like Google's play store is doing well with 24.8 Billion dollars of Worldwide gross app revenue [0] as of 2018. Awhile ago Oracle gave an estimate of 31 billion dollars as an estimate of total revenue [2] but that seemed like a high estimate to me.

0-https://www.statista.com/statistics/444476/google-play-annua... 1-https://www.statista.com/statistics/281106/number-of-android... 2-https://www.businessinsider.com/oracle-android-generates-31-...

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by gibolt on Thursday August 15, 2019 @05:11PM (#20709706)
Revenue is not profit. Only a percentage will go to Google. It is still a big number and certainly profitable, but developing/maintaining the store and Android are both very expensive.
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by henryfjordan on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:00PM (#20708488)
You're not wrong, Android and Google will always be buddies as long as Google is top dog. But, if you break Android out of Google it allows shareholders to challenge decisions by the management of Android.

There'd at least be the legal hurdle that Google has to actually always be the best choice. Bing could theoretically offer more for the top slot and Android can't factor in the other intangibles of putting Google first anyway like they currently do.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by ijpoijpoihpiuoh on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:52PM (#20708983)
Theoretically. But if they're not willing to offer top dollar for iOS, they sure won't for Android. And anyway, if they value Android spots so much, they will be able to bid in this auction and appear on the list. The list is randomized on each startup, so it doesn't matter whether Google bids more than Bing. The only thing that matters is who bids for fourth place and who bids for fifth. I sincerely doubt that anyone believes Google would fail to bid in the top four.

TBH, I find it really interesting that people are complaining so much about this. It's actually a much more competition friendly approach, and less beneficial to Google, than what Apple does with iOS' search default. I guess it's a little different in that for iOS it is Apple aiding and abetting Google's monopoly, whereas with Android it seems like self-dealing. But I have yet to see a suggestion for something else to do that leads to a reasonable outcome.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by zaphirplane on Thursday August 15, 2019 @09:49PM (#20711480)
The owners would be the same initially. The board would be different and Over time the ownership would drift. I don’t think equity and funds managers would view the payments between the 2 companies to be not real
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by handedness on Thursday August 15, 2019 @03:36PM (#20708845)
I'm open to the idea of breaking them up and separating the paid and organic sides more fully (and with much more outside accountability, but the auction model isn't terribly instructive.

Auction houses virtually always charge fees, typically as a percent of the close price, with some allocated against the buyer, some against the seller (on the order of ~5-15% on each side).

They also have listing fees for sellers and bidder registration fees for buyers, so if no lots change hands they still cover their expenses.

The requisite hotel rooms for the auction staff are typically comped by the hotel attached to the venue, and venues are often comped as they attract bidder bookings during otherwise slow periods.

Auction houses don't pay themselves to list their own items or merchandize their own services.

It's almost pure upside the auction house. Their big risk is nobody will register to bid and/or buy and next year's auction is dead in the water.

In Google's case, the advertiser is covering both fees, and the user is "paying" (if you will) in terms of giving up their personal data in exchange for search results (more or less) so Google can charge their pool of advertisers more (in aggregate).

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by easytiger on Friday August 16, 2019 @01:56AM (#20712510)
> The solution is to break up Google, and force Google to bid for the right to show up on the list on Android-the-company's platform just like everyone else.

A very worrying trend that people support such things so blindly.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by GuiA on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:11PM (#20707258)
> Essentially creating a scenario where no matter who is chosen, Google wins

Given that this is something entirely orchestrated by Google in an attempt to make lawmakers think that competition is A-OK and no legislation is needed to curb Google’s power, this kind of thing is to be expected.

Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by ocdtrekkie on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:15PM (#20707299)
On the contrary, I think this plan took a lot of gall to come up with. If Google's trying to avoid legislation, it should be "self-regulating" itself hard to try and prove legislation isn't needed. But this system is pretty transparent what it is doing and the EU is going to see right through it.
Re:Google’s rivals opt out of search engine auction, calling... by GuiA on Thursday August 15, 2019 @01:18PM (#20707345)
It’s a closed auction run on their own terms, that excludes entire classes of alternative search engines by design.

A “lot of gall” is a very generous interpretation.