News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vote to amend the DMCA and help music apps like Groovesha... by jessriedel on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @03:21AM (#2070350)
> I'm mainly talking morally and ethically

I think there's a huge moral difference between your right to your shoes and your right to some idea. Here are some things that make it hard to believe IP is a good fundamental right (in the sense of Locke):

* Bob and Joe on opposite sides of the world have no problem with each owning a pair of shoes. But if Bob invents a device on Tuesday, and Joe independently invents in on Wednesday, why should Bob get everything and Joe nothing? Yes, from a practical standpoint it's necessary to give patents solely to the first-mover; otherwise people would pretend to invent existing things. But why should time-of-invention matter morally...at all?

* Should Shakespeare's heirs (or, more realistically, a copyright-holding corporation) really be able to dictate how his plays are used today? And forever? If not, what moral principle would we use to choose a time limit?

* Why, if IP is a moral right, are mathematical theorems not ownable?

* It's not to hard to distinguish things which are physically ownable, but where does one draw the line with IP? How detailed must my graphic design be for it to be mine forever? Can I own all green squares, or only green squares inside of blue hexagons? Legally, the threshold for copyright is set to try to maximize societal benefit. But if copyrights are moral rights existing independent of any legal framework, on what moral principle could one decide what's copyright-able?

Re:Vote to amend the DMCA and help music apps like Groovesha... by Natsu on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @04:20AM (#2070456)
Indeed. There are plenty of other arguments, too, based on game theory, which I should hope any mathematician or economist would appreciate. Some good papers and discussion can be found at these sites:

* http://levine.sscnet.ucla.edu/index.htm

* http://www.againstmonopoly.org/

Re:Vote to amend the DMCA and help music apps like Groovesha... by jessriedel on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @02:17PM (#2072063)
Well, those seem to be econ/math arguments which assume a utilitarian(-like) moral philosophy. I was trying to convince citricsquid with a philosophical argument that IP is probably not a good fundamental right, whether or not you're a utilitarian.
Re:Vote to amend the DMCA and help music apps like Groovesha... by Natsu on Wednesday January 05, 2011 @02:56PM (#2072221)
True. I wasn't trying to take away from your post. I just thought I'd add that, because it ought to be relevant to a fair number of the hackers here.