Re:Project Mu – A modular UEFI environment for building mode...
by pgeorgi on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @07:19PM
(#20701010)
The Management Engine is very a different beast, if only because its code runs long before the main x86 CPU is even started (and UEFI can run). It also seems to run Minix these days (and before they moved the ME to the tiny Quark-style x86 core, some RTOS on an ARC core).
Unlike the ME firmware, SMM code is usually built with, shipped with and loaded by the x86 firmware.
Re:Project Mu – A modular UEFI environment for building mode...
by non-entity on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @08:55PM
(#20701607)
Pardon the interruption, but I know what all these term are (UEFI, ME, SMM) on a very cursory level, but this thread is sparking g my curiosity. Do you know of any good books / websites / etc. That docs good job of explaining how all these pieces work together in modern processors and firmware?
And yeah I'm sure places like Google that control the whole stack have the ability and will to get rid of SMM for their own systems but that doesn't make sense for the vast majority of systems, particularly from white box vendors. As an example, new archs like AArch64 and RISC-V have equivalents in EL3/PSCI and Monitor Mode (mandated in all chips) respectively. The concept of a piece of code shipped by your board vendor running under the OS and hypervisor for system management tasks is just too useful of a concept.