We track all the properties in our portfolio daily. Any on paper depreciation will result in us depositing funds into the 3rd party account. Whenever a property price moves above the original purchase price on paper, we will withdraw any previously deposited fund. This on-going process along with the hedging instruments are what allows us to guarantee the downside protection.
As a final layer of protection, we know exactly what our on going exposure is, so we know the maximum amount of contracts we can underwrite. We are very strict on this number and will never move above it. So, even if our company ceases operations, all of the downside protection will still be available to our customers.
Keep in mind, we also know exactly what our on going
Can you expound on this a bit? If you go under, who would I have to go to get paid? What legal guarantees would I have in place assuring me the payout? How do I know that your underwriting scheme is sufficient for covering your exposure?
In terms of our our underwriting process works. We do have clauses in our contract that removes our liability for act of god events, civil strife, or war. Barring these scenarios, the only other events that can move a property's depreciation to more than 20% is a recession scenario, which the hedging instruments would cover.
So, in reality, our exposure for every home is between 0 to -20%. So for every home we underwrite, we just need to mark funds equal to 20% of the property value.
Is this clear? If not, I'm happy to expand on it further?
So how does it work if your system values a property above what it's actually able to sell for? It sounds like so long as you value the property at or above the initial purchase price, there is $0 set aside to pay out any loss of value claims. If the owner sells into a falling market, and needs to sell for less than the initial price how can you pay out? Why wouldnt they just take any price they can get if they have 100% downside protection?
Moreso - if the overall housing market is falling, how does the business survive if all of your customers sell at a loss? I can't think why someone wouldn't sell if they have 100% downside protection and can then move into a cheaper home.
In the event that a customer wants to buy us out after 3 years. The rate used to calculate change in on paper value is derived from the median home price rate of change from that neighborhood. The value comes from the MLS and it's a rate that neither we as a company nor our customer can artificially manipulate. So, we think it's the best representation of the market change.
If the overall house market is falling, our hedging instruments will provide us enough revenue to offset our customer's losses. If it's not a market wide recession, the gains from some contracts should very easily offset some of the losses along with our own capital we use to guarantee the loss.
These methods combined should allow us to guarantee the losses in all different market scenarios.
What happens if I buy today and your company goes to hell in two years? How can I trust this transaction with a horizon of 3 years without fully knowing how are you going to perform as a company.
Of course, if you disappear and I don't have to honor the 20% it's a win for me, but if I buy based on your data and after 3 years the property value is way down and you're not around to honor your loss-covering promise then I'm fucked. I bought a house because you told me it was going to appreciate, but it didn't. Now what? Do you have a way to pay me back even if your company is not around anymore?
There's something about the model that doesn't make sense to me.