News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The 1619 Project by em3rgent0rdr on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @12:36PM (#20697210)
> "If you wanted to understand the brutality of American capitalism..."

Stopped reading there. Not sure American capitalism is some evil brutal thing to oppose in the first place. And we could have capitalism without having slavery.

Re:The 1619 Project by danso on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @12:53PM (#20697389)
That quote comes from the headline of this fairly in-depth essay: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/08/14/magazine/slav...

In the context of 19th-century history, I don't think calling out American capitalism as being particularly brutal is that controversial. Considering one of our most lionized presidents – one of the 4 immortalized on Mount Rushmore – is arguably most famous for sweeping economic reforms and regulations. And this was decades after slavery.

> And we could have capitalism without having slavery

But we didn't, and this is ostensibly one of the themes of this project. That slavery is inextricable from America's founding economic success, so it's inaccurate to view something so foundational as simply an unfortunate misstep.

Re:The 1619 Project by istjohn on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @01:05PM (#20697537)
In addition to slavery, American businesses have been behind exploitation and despotism in Latin America and Africa. American capitalism has certainly been brutal.
Re:The 1619 Project by manfredo on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @02:35PM (#20698552)
I think the issue is the erroneous claim that slavery was a product of capitalism. This is patently untrue, slavery predates capitalism by millennia.

Not only that, a strong argument can be made that capitalism ended slavery. The American South was an agrarian society, with an economy based on crops. The North was a capitalist society with industry forming a much larger portion of the economy. It was the industrialist, capitalist North that voted an abolitionist President into office and defeated the South's subsequent rebellion.

This pattern holds true across global history. Agrarian societies have almost always had some mechanism to lock large segments of the population into agricultural or manual labor: caste systems, serfdom, slavery all filled this role with some variation in their implementation. Abolition movements predominantly occurred in the time range from 1750 to 1900, and in the same time period many countries began to industrialize.

Re:The 1619 Project by mcguire on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @04:29PM (#20699612)
I think you're confusing the difference between capitalism and industrialism.
Re:The 1619 Project by manfredo on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @04:32PM (#20699645)
The two largely go hand in hand. You need capital to start new industries. Industrialism, in turn, generates lots of capital that people are going to want to invest thus leading to more capitalist activity. Industrialism without capitalism has been attempted in the USSR and PRC, both of which ended up adopting capitalism. No industrial society managed to remain non-capitalist for more than 50-60 years which is incredibly short in the context of global history.
Re:The 1619 Project by aflag on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @04:55PM (#20699857)
You also need capital to start new plantations. Which, in turn, also generates lots of capital that people are going to want to invest thus leading to bigger and more plantations.

Industrialism did make slavery obsolete and, where still needed, easy to offshore. Which I think is what described ended slavery in the US

Re:The 1619 Project by manfredo on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @05:13PM (#20700003)
No, you don't need capital to start plantations. You just need land and labor. People were running farms and plantations thousands of years before coinage was invented.

Plantation owners are capitalists in the same vein that Romans were capitalists when they conquered neighbors and cultivated this newly annexed land. This is perhaps correct in a very abstract sense of capitalism, but it is an alternative definition that is not shared by most people and most people will say you are wrong if you try to claim that this is capitalism.

Re:The 1619 Project by Avshalom on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @12:41PM (#20697261)
we could have, but we didn't.
Re:The 1619 Project by eej71 on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @12:54PM (#20697397)
Capitalism did not create slavery. It inherited it.
Re:The 1619 Project by dsr_ on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @01:11PM (#20697598)
But surely you agree that as soon as anyone realized that slavery is wrong, their duty is to shut it down immediately?

Capitalism did not do that.

Re:The 1619 Project by dsr_ on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @03:34PM (#20699100)
2 hours later, there are at least three people on HN who don't agree, but aren't brave enough to make a comment so we can see who they are.
Re:The 1619 Project by eej71 on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @04:21PM (#20699525)
Your prior comment makes it sound like it was a light switch that people were reluctant to throw. I see the bloody and protracted nature of the Civil War as evidence for just how difficult it was to end - even in the 1860s! I'm grateful the North didn't give up. It's a miracle they kept at it.
Re:The 1619 Project by earthboundkid on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @01:50PM (#20698051)
I don't think that's a good summary. Yes, there were always enslaved people. But the transatlantic system was something new.

Why didn't the colonizers just use European serfs as slaves in America? Because the Europeans already had a norm against serious abuse of serfs. Why didn't they enslave the Native Americans? They tried, but the indigenous all were dying of European diseases. So they brought in a third party, the Africans. Sure, Africans had been enslaving each other, but it wasn't worse than what Europeans did to serfs. When the Europeans enslaved the Africans, suddenly things got a lot worse than it had ever been in the history of slavery. Just incredible cruelty, but even more than that, the new element of skin color based discrimination. That had never really been a thing before, but to justify being this cruel to Africans, you needed a powerful ideology. In some countries, this led to a color system where your proximity to power was roughly equal to your degree of darkness, but in the US, we evolved a "one drop" rule where people were either classified as white or non-white with no half-measures. (This was also bad for mixed European/Native Americans, as well as those of African heritage.)

"Capitalism" is a fuzzy term that is hard to pin down, but to the degree that it means something, I think it's fair to say: after the Columbian contact, the European economic system led to transatlantic slavery, transatlantic slavery was something new in the world and led to modern racism (which is distinct from mere xenophobia), and racism has lived long beyond the end of the legal slave system and taken on a life of its own. Capitalism inherited slavery but then refashioned it and birthed new evils.

Re:The 1619 Project by rdm70 on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @02:19PM (#20698387)
In the early colonial period, the colonizers did use European as near slaves. Many thousands of people came from Europe as indentured servants for seven year contracts, and few survived the harsh conditions for the full seven years.

For forty years (1619-1661), Black Africans came to Virginia as indentured servants rather than slaves. Then Virginia passed a slave law. Slaves were cheaper.

Citation. https://www.pbs.org/opb/historydetectives/feature/indentured...

Re:The 1619 Project by earthboundkid on Thursday August 15, 2019 @10:28AM (#20705507)
That doesn't go against what I'm saying. The point is that "slavery" had always been around but then it turned into something much eviler and worse. Those European slaves didn't have their condition inherited by their children through to 1865. The African indentured servants didn't go on to gain the freedom of European indentured servants. (Yes, there were many freeman Africans in pre-Civil War America, but the point of Dredd Scott was that their citizenship was only provisional.)

European indentured servants didn't have the women raped and the children of that union enslaved. Look at the skin color of the average African American and the average West African. Virtually every African American alive today has some European ancestry. This process of raping women and then enslaving the children produced by rape was not a normal aspect of global slavery.

Is it fair to blame this on "capitalism"? That question depends a lot on the semantics of what we mean by "capitalism". But at the very least, we need to explain why slavery went from being the equivalent of being alive today and working at Foxxconn (sucks but hey, that's life) to being in the Lord's Resistance Army (hell on earth).

Re:The 1619 Project by untog on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @12:57PM (#20697435)
> Stopped reading there. Not sure American capitalism is some evil brutal thing to oppose in the first place.

Maybe if you didn't stop reading you could have read the whole essay and formed an opinion based on that, rather that on one line of text?

I don't mean to sound unnecessarily mean, but stopping reading the very second you see something objectionable strikes me as very closed-minded.