News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Planet: Imaging the entire Earth every day by dougmwne on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @06:52AM (#20694217)
No way, not even close. At this point Google is doing overhead lidar flights to get incredibly details 3d maps. The Planet imagry is like going back several decades in satellite tech. But on the other hand, it's daily.
Re:Planet: Imaging the entire Earth every day by gjstein on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @10:14AM (#20695743)
Do you have a source for "overhead LIDAR flights"? I was under the impression that data was coming almost exclusively from their StreetView cars (with perhaps a few companies that provide helicopter-based data from time to time). True enough though that Google has a staggering amount of data about the earth.
Re:Planet: Imaging the entire Earth every day by dougmwne on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @10:28AM (#20695888)
My apologies. I remembered incorrectly. The aerial flights use computer vision to extract depth maps. While aerial LIDAR is used in GIS, I could not find LIDAR mentioned connected with Google's aerial imagery.

https://blog.google/products/earth/google-earths-incredible-...

Re:Planet: Imaging the entire Earth every day by thejj100100 on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @10:30AM (#20695909)
Yeah we had a motorhome outside our house and I looked at the 3D map and it showed even though street view car hasn’t visited since 2013. A few months later it updated and showed without the motorhome yet gain without streetview car.
Re:Planet: Imaging the entire Earth every day by RosanaAnaDana on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @10:58AM (#20696217)
Google imagery is a wide range of 10-100cm imagery. I believe (top of my head) that the planet data is natively 25 centimeters (7-8 band?).
Re:Planet: Imaging the entire Earth every day by jofer on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @01:08PM (#20697568)
Planet global imagery is 4 band sampled at ~4m (oversampled to 3.0m). Skysats (Planet's high-res satellites) are 0.8m, but image only small areas. (Numbers are based on https://assets.planet.com/docs/combined-imagery-product-spec...)

Nothing is global at high resolution for anyone. Google's imagery is only high res at locations people are likely to look at.

High resolution satellites have a very narrow field of view. You can't image a large area with them. Ditto for aerial. There simply isn't 1m or better imagery globally, let alone 100cm.

Re:Planet: Imaging the entire Earth every day by branchan on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @01:17PM (#20697657)
I don't think that has anything to do with field of view. It's just that higher res = higher cost so they can't afford to have high res global coverage at LEO.
Re:Planet: Imaging the entire Earth every day by jofer on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @01:28PM (#20697796)
It really does have a lot do do with field of view. High res satellites fundamentally can't image a very large area (that's how a telescope works). They also usually can't image continuously. (High res means you can't image at the rate you're moving without significant SNR drawbacks - you have to stay pointed the target so that you have a long enough exposure time. You can get around this to some degree, but either way, high-res sats are designed for bursts of targeted imaging.)

You need _way_ more high-res sats than are currently in operation to image the entire land surface of the planet even yearly. So, yes, higher cost, but probably beyond what a company like google could pay. (Think trillions, not billions)

Re:Planet: Imaging the entire Earth every day by Bedon292 on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @02:26PM (#20698458)
To emphasize on this: WorldView 4, which has ~31cm pan imagery came to a cost of about $850M. And is the size of a school bus. Vs the significantly smaller and less expensive stalites Planet uses. And unfortunately that stallite had a failur and only was usable for a bit over 2 years. High res satellites are really hard still.
Re:Planet: Imaging the entire Earth every day by RosanaAnaDana on Friday August 16, 2019 @11:12AM (#20715942)
Yeah, I got my satellite companies confused. I was thinking of digital globe and their 31 cm offering (got a quote from them fairly recently).