News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Freakonomics: Game Theory and Child-Rearing by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @07:26PM (#2069227)
>No lying at all. You're just taking a concrete rule and setting soft and hard boundaries.

Ah, when you said boundaries I thought you meant [hard] boundaries not soft limits.

>But set them so that hard boundaries aren't reached.

If they test the boundaries and can't reach the hard boundary then the hard boundary is somewhere else isn't it? I realise you said "aren't" but that appears to require more mental agility and less will than I remember of a 2-3yo.

>you can expect to see exploration of how far over the line the toe can go before being told to come back

If the toe is over the line then that's not acceptable, for me the line represents the point at which the apparent danger becomes too large. I'm not letting them over the line but they can stand and look at "danger". My 20-ish month old has just started copying an older sibling and attempting to stand on the arms of chairs, standing on the seat (at home) is fine, on the arms isn't. He puts his foot up, I say "no" and he takes it down (mostly; learned response from other situations). 3yo can manage stairs all right can't they (it's been a couple of years).

My attitude is to try and allow behaviour which isn't negative. Singing at the meal table, fine. Singing with mouth full at meal table, not fine (splattered food that needs cleaning up). FWIW I find this very hard to live to.

I think we've compressed the grey area, there must be one still but because it's small I have a hard time imagining situations that match your descriptions.

Thanks for the book recommendation, if I had money I'd buy it. Was there a specific aspect of the book you felt I should take on board?

Re:Freakonomics: Game Theory and Child-Rearing by btilly on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @08:18PM (#2069376)
I said set limits so that hard boundaries aren't reached, not so that they can't be. If I'm across the room, my kid can get to the head of the stairs before I get there. But her exploratory game is at the soft boundary, with no intent to cross the hard one, so she never does that.

And yes, she can navigate the stairs just fine. But they are steep and large for her, so the rule is that she is only allowed to do it under close adult supervision, holding on to the railing, etc.

As for the book, I have no idea which aspect of the book would benefit you. For me, personally, the biggest piece is that it taught me a lot about how attachment works, and I discovered that one of my deficiencies is that I didn't listen enough to how my kids want to engage me (rather than having me actively engage them).