Edit: Costs are already so low that the only way to increase net profits would be to increase revenue per user, perhaps with added micropayments, but it seems to me that with so few paying users <1200, I should be trying to get a larger user base and then later increase revenue per user?
Or set up an affiliate program paying about $1 per free signup.
I get people via Adwords at less than 20 cents a click. According to Facebook, the minimum bid for people who like online games or mmorpgs, or other categories I've tried is currently well over a dollar. I did get some clicks from Facebook when their ads were fairly new and the minimum bids weren't so high, but conversion rates were much lower than those from Adwords.
- increase your price (see: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1639712).
- consider partnering with sites that you select to send you traffic and give them a kickback of for instance $20 / signup.
With a retention like that you could drop your conversion rate even further (so market more aggressively) and still come out on top.
Don't bother optimizing the conversion, the retention or any simple formula but instead focus on optimizing the one number that matters: net profits.