Re:I suck at web design, so I made a contest to design rubyc...
by tptacek on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @02:14PM
(#2068065)
There is indeed evil at Crowdspring and 99designs, though it's not on the offer side; designers routinely submit plagiarized work to contests. It's something you always have to be on the lookout for and it's a major downside of using those sites.
Re:I suck at web design, so I made a contest to design rubyc...
by lwhi on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @04:50PM
(#2068682)
Creating an environment where people regularly work for the chance of being paid, is immoral imo.
You can argue that no one forces these people to work - but that same argument could also be used by the proprietor of a child-labour camp or sweat shop.
And if they're not, they still have the option of not participating!
That's what drives me nuts about all this "no-spec!/crowdsourcing is eeeevil!" chat on the Internet. Nobody's forcing anyone to participate.
There's a very (very, very) large group of people who only have $500 to spend on branding their company. If someone can't/won't spend $10k to a "branding agency", should they not be allowed to have a logo at all?
There are even MORE people who are willing to do a little work for the chance of winning $500 and seeing their work used by people not related to them.
Disclaimer: I used to work at crowdspring. I've literally seen both sides of hundreds of these contests. Nobody's evil and everyone participating knows the risks of participating. It's a win-win.