Re:Freakonomics: Game Theory and Child-Rearing
by johngalt on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @07:24PM
(#2069226)
Until little Johnny(kid1) figures out that being stuck in his room is more palatible to him than it is to little Susie(kid2). Then he wins every disagreement by fiat.
Gaining power over your sibling wouldn't be described as a bad consequence to most children.
It's also rather vague, while effective parenting is distressingly high on specifics. The "secret" (if you would call it that) described here would appear to fit your description — there's a bad consequence for fighting and a good consequence for apologizing.