The US generally has a legal system that acknowledges joint and several liability, so the bank and criminal are independently 100% liable...and guess who the damaged party is more likely to get satisfaction from?
Being a bank is a privilege, a highly regulated privilege at that. It sort of goes without saying the bank violate their duties and was not complying with bank regulations where the opened up an account on behalf of someone using the identification of a 3rd party.
Don't like those regulations? Think they are to burdensome? Then Wells Fargo can give their bank charter.
People often wonder how this is fair. If parties D1 and D2 both played a role in allowing some bad thing to happen to P, but it was 90% D1's fault and 10% D2's fault, but D2 has deep pockets and D1 has almost nothing, how is it fair to make D2 pay both their own share and D1's share of the damages to P?
It makes a lot more sense when you realize that these are situations where someone has to get screwed. If D1 is liable to P for 90% of the total damages and D2 is liable to P for 10% of the total damages, P gets screwed. P only gets 10% of what they are owed.
Joint and several liability recognizes that of the parties involved P is the one who least deserves to get screwed, and so allows P to collect the full damage award from whichever D's have the money. If, as in this example, that results in one or more D's getting screwed, those D's can sue the other D's over it.
And that will fairly be debated until the end of time. Some jurisdictions do not have joint and several liability and so your example of liability being capped up to their % of their contributory negligence is a reality. Even in the joint and severally liable jurisdictions, there will be a finding of contributory negligence, but its pretty well understood a jury can't fairly assign %'s of fault anyway.
However, as someone who sees the reality of these cases, the guy with the deep pockets really doesn't pay either, their insurance pays, and this is really where things get both weird and fair. Say you hit me with your car and I file a claim with my insurance and your insurance, the insurance companies work it out behind the scene (and I promise they do these settlements in their own best interest, not the insured (your) or the claimants best interests (mine)) and insurance does this knowing tomorrow they will work together on another claim where the other insurance company will be liable.
Insurance issues aside, if it weren't for joint and several liability these deep pockets you reference would never be liable, they would always out spend the criminal defendant in attorney's fees and likely be attributed almost no % of liability. Joint and several liability encourages the fair settlement of cases to save time and money to all parties, and gives the claimant the best chance of being made whole, whereas these other system encourages outspending the other parties in litigation and disincentives settlements of claims, shifting a lot of costs on tax payers who pay for the courts.
Specifically, my argument would be that Wells Fargo was in a position to verify the criminal's claimed identity, but didn't.
I don't think this is really about liability for the direct cost of the fraudulent transaction, though.
It sounds like third parties (banks, credit providers, etc) have been libelling the reporter by claiming to other third parties (credit agencies, law enforcement, etc) that he did things that he didn't. They should be expected to verify identity more carefully before making such strong claims like that, and should be liable to the reporter for damages caused as a consequence of their negligence.
Likewise, if law enforcement has been told about the fraud, then they should be held to account for harassing this unrelated party.
The Bloomberg reporter's problems weren't that he had to pay a bunch of money because a fraudster did a bunch of stuff using his name. His problems were all related to his damaged reputation (credit score, government lists, etc).
Note that if it was your own bank that defamed you, then you may have signed an arbitration agreement.
If the bank claims that I have a delinquent loan, and that claim is false due to their negligence, then they should be liable for all the consequences.
In Europe a more usual consequence would be that if a bad credit is reported and disputed (because it's not mine) then (a) the disputed bad credit notice would have to be immediately removed until the dispute is resolved; (b) the burden of proof is up to the institution, not the borrower; and (c) "a guy came in, claimed to be you, and knew your ID number and your mom's maiden name" is not considered proof. So the end result is that they'd be out of money and my credit would still be clean.
This also means that any institutions with lax ID policies will be heavily targeted by fraudsters. If you're the only car rental (for example) which doesn't properly verify identity, then every crook in the country (and beyond) will come and visit your office. For example, banks used to take scans of the ID used - if the picture they have is not your real ID, then there's no dispute that it's not you; and if it's your real ID and it was reported as lost/stolen beforehand (companies can query that data), then there's no dispute, their claims are not valid and they're not allowed to tell any other companies (credit registers/etc) that you have a bad debt because that's libel and they'd be liable for any damages.
If they think that I'm just faking that claim, they're free to go to the police and press charges that I did take that loan and I'm defrauding them by these false statements. Then it's a criminal case - serious consequences, but also serious burden of proof.
Or they're free to go to the police with surveillance cam footage of the person who took that loan and have them look for the fraudster.
And things like the regulations for managing credit scores and government lists are things that the gov't can (and should) change to remove undue burden from the person whos identity was used by fraudsters.
At the end of the day, his problem is exactly that he had to pay a massive cost (in the form of reputational damage and tremendous wastes of his time) because a fraudster did a bunch of stuff using his name. While not technically monetary, it's definitely not impossible to financially quantify people's time and reputation.
Surely the identity thief, the actual criminal who committed fraud, should be liable?