https://www.robeco.com/en/insights/2017/09/research-reveals-...
Essentially, sin stocks are unusually well managed because they can't be used for empire-building by crappy executives.
If there is a climate catastrophe going to happen, but no government is going to punish companies responsible, it won't make sense to try to do that for yourself -- in the same way bad corporations are freeriding on climate, bad investors are freeriding on your efforts to punish such corporations.
Investors and traders eat uncertainty for breakfast, lunch and dinner. It doesn’t stop them from making trading decisions. It’s what keeps market ticking.
Trying to reason about whether the stock market is a good battleground. If you know I wouldn't want to buy your investment, surely that lowers how much you'd value it, as does the potential for having to pay a premium on bonds. As a CEO your share based compensation starts to look less attractive as does the whole idea of presiding over a company potentially on the wrong did of history. So I wouldn't say its a pointless battle.
Lets take Uber, on one level its worth billions, but it makes no money, if everyone avoided the stock and debt it would run into problems pretty quickly. It is worth billions only because sufficient people believe it is/ will be worth that much, if enough people avoid it, it isn't going to be worth that.
These active investors don't even have to realize their strategy is based on going against nice guys -- they might be led purely by statistical performance.
I'm not trying to be needlessly cynical. I like effective altruism for example. I'm just not sure stock market is a good battleground for ethics.