News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: 20+ Postings in 20 minutes of HN. Is this conside... by jasonkester on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @11:05AM (#2067407)
Indeed, people are here seeking karma for its own sake. That's the problem.

It's also the reason why every single techcrunch article get submitted here. There was a time where you'd see maybe one TC article a week come through, usually with discussion as to whether it was really worth being here.

Realistically, maybe half a dozen articles per day are high enough quality to even be submitted here. The fact that we're seeing thousands each day is a sign that standards have fallen drastically. Removing the incentive to post things unless they're really good would go a long way toward improving the signal to noise ratio.

Re:Ask HN: 20+ Postings in 20 minutes of HN. Is this conside... by srean on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @11:16AM (#2067449)
Your comment made me think of a scheme where a post automatically incurs a tiny negative karma, which can be compensated and exceeded by the karma awarded by the community. Right now we do not have any dis-incentive for posting noise. It will make posters think twice.

However karma has to be made a float as opposed to an integer. I am curious, do downvoters get a tiny hit for downvoting ?

Re:Ask HN: 20+ Postings in 20 minutes of HN. Is this conside... by secret on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @12:43PM (#2067769)
I agree there should be a cost for posting stories, even going so far as preventing further submissions if you fall below a certain threshold. You could raise your karma back up through commenting.