That sounds so dystopian
And gun violence in America has already shown what happens when we don't take common sense measures such as this seriously. If you knew someone had a 50% chance of shooting up a Walmart, would you casually say "Well we don't know that fro sure." or would you make a list of all of those suspicious people and track them?
We already have what is a dystopian credit scoring system, and I don't see people in a panic, or protesting in the streets, excepting for an occasional person writing that their data is used unfairly.
I'm in agreement really. If people don't want their information used for a credit score, they should be able to refuse to have their info used for it, but of course that comes at the cost of not having good credit.
Social credit scores could function quite similarly.
If someone picked me up based on fingerprints, I would much rather them say "We found prints matching yours at this crime scene. Statistically, there are 5 other people with prints like that in the area. We have circumstantial evidence that points to you as well. Since we aren't certain, but we have your prints we'll fine you 1/5th of the full amount for the regular violation." Currently, we make mistakes that lock people up for years based upon uncertain accusations - it's always all or nothing. This puts way too much pressure on investigators to get it right and in the case of murders, put someone away no matter what.
I'll tell you what - if they're going to make the mistake anyway, I'd rather have 1/5th to 1/20th of the time to serve.
Edit: This is the 21st century. We're also not restricted to simply imprisonment. Other factors can be affected. It would be interesting if labels could be placed upon those who are suspect, like "suspicious". This could prevent certain purchases and types of travel which would make the kinds of crimes they are suspected of committing more difficult.