Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone
by tptacek on Friday August 09, 2019 @04:35AM
(#20652337)
This is silly. Apple is going to have bugs almost no matter what they do, as will Google and Microsoft.
It makes sense to invest way over the top if you can kill bug classes outright --- and Apple does this, too. For example, people that were doing DMA hardware attacks against macOS a couple years ago are now on Apple's payroll, designing hardware to defend against those attacks. That's a meaningful serious investment in defense. Rewriting their kernel in a memory safe language would be another example (one they haven't done yet).
Massively outbidding the current spot price for a bug doesn't accomplish anything like that. Think about who they're really bidding against. They can drive the price of bugs way up, and they are doing that gradually, but there will still be a price and people selling them.
The important thing they're doing on this is making unlocked devices available for researchers, and lowering the bar for research for people who would never sell to brokers.
It makes sense to invest way over the top if you can kill bug classes outright --- and Apple does this, too. For example, people that were doing DMA hardware attacks against macOS a couple years ago are now on Apple's payroll, designing hardware to defend against those attacks. That's a meaningful serious investment in defense. Rewriting their kernel in a memory safe language would be another example (one they haven't done yet).
Massively outbidding the current spot price for a bug doesn't accomplish anything like that. Think about who they're really bidding against. They can drive the price of bugs way up, and they are doing that gradually, but there will still be a price and people selling them.
The important thing they're doing on this is making unlocked devices available for researchers, and lowering the bar for research for people who would never sell to brokers.