News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by freedomben on Thursday August 08, 2019 @10:29PM (#20650872)
I don't know how Canada does it, but a lot of those smiles would change at least a little bit in the US when they get a 1099-C in February and realize the IRS counts debt forgiveness as taxable lump-sum income.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by nrdgrl on Thursday August 08, 2019 @10:44PM (#20650940)
Yikes. Nope, I live in Canada and I had a few tens of thousands in debt forgiven. Definitely didn't have to pay taxes on it. That would be absolutely crazy and would have driven me to bankruptcy!
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by iscrewyou on Thursday August 08, 2019 @11:20PM (#20651080)
Not judging you at all, I promise. I found it ironically funny that forgiving debt could lead someone into bankruptcy. Talk about a win-win situation.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by freedomben on Thursday August 08, 2019 @11:28PM (#20651115)
Yep. In my case we were overjoyed having finally worked out a deal with the bank, only to discover that now I was in debt to the IRS instead of the bank :'(

It sure feels like your government is shitting on you during an already tough situation.

Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by dmix on Friday August 09, 2019 @01:08AM (#20651476)
So the idea is the bank gave you a loan then forgave it, so it’s now income? That’s a big leap in logic and sounds evil considering you never consider that when getting a loan, you only expect the internet to accrue.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by briandear on Friday August 09, 2019 @01:31AM (#20651579)
It is income. Someone gave you money. Otherwise, why wouldn’t a company “loan” you a higher salary and then just “forgive” the debt? Or, you could set up a company to loan yourself money — the company deducts the “loss” and you don’t pay taxes on the gain.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by Retric on Friday August 09, 2019 @07:39AM (#20653349)
The principal is presumably income, however the interest or fees should not be. The IRS will even occasionally cancel debt that’s mostly fines and interest without considering it income.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by dmix on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:24AM (#20651765)
Like all laws there should be some context. But I guess you’re right it’s an easy loophole to exploit and the simpler the tax law the better.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by dsfyu404ed on Friday August 09, 2019 @07:57AM (#20653474)
The IRS definitely (as definite as a capricious federal bureaucracy can be) let you make payments on the taxes in that situation.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by colejohnson66 on Friday August 09, 2019 @12:19PM (#20655742)
This. Despite what many people think, the IRS doesn’t want to bankrupt people. They’ll work with you and set up a payment plan if necessary.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by freedomben on Thursday August 08, 2019 @11:26PM (#20651107)
Yep me too. It's crazy. I had to consult with a bankruptcy lawyer because of this. I couldn't believe it.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by homakov on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:39AM (#20652091)
What kind of amount in tax are you talking about? Is it net profit anyway compared to paying back tens of thousands?
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by michaelanckaert on Friday August 09, 2019 @01:35AM (#20651593)
Seems logical to me: the bank essentially gave you a loan and then said, well you don’t need to pay us back. So they really gave you a certain amount of money. Isn’t that what they call income?
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by lostphilosopher on Friday August 09, 2019 @05:27AM (#20652666)
Not disagreeing, but calling out that if you get a significant lump sum you can easily set aside x% for taxes, but if you get the same amount of debt forgiven there's no pot to "set aside" from. You need to come up with that money now* from your existing money which can be challenging if the forgiven amount was significant.

* Granted, you can usually arrange to pay a large tax bill over time, but that is basically debt which you'll be annoyed/surprised to find yourself back in...

Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by Scoundreller on Thursday August 08, 2019 @10:31PM (#20650882)
According to the article, it's only the case if you were using the card for business.

And if you were a business that couldn't pay your 27.99% credit card for 16+ months, you have losses to count it against.

Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by eridius on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:51AM (#20651885)
Presumably the article is talking about Canadian tax laws, whereas the parent is talking about US tax laws.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by e12e on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:32AM (#20651801)
But if you borrowed 100 dollars at 20 interest (ie credit card) and ended up being forgiven a 1000 dollar debt - is that 100 or 1000 dollar to pay taxes on?
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by LoSboccacc on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:52AM (#20652142)
it's 1000
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by jerkstate on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:59AM (#20652173)
But if you loan someone $100 at 20% interest and write it off when it's $1000, it's a $100 deduction.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by gruez on Friday August 09, 2019 @08:42AM (#20653746)
That's not how write offs work. If you spent $100 on materials making a widget, and valued it at $1000, then somehow lost it (eg. stolen, non paying customer), your profit is -$100[1], not -$1000. Likewise, you can't claim a $1000 loss on that debt, only $100. The only way you can claim $1000 is if you previously recorded the $900 in interest as profit (and paid taxes on it).

[1]

    profit = revenue - cost
           = 0 - $100
           = -$100
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by e12e on Friday August 09, 2019 @05:53PM (#20658510)
Is it? You're holding a contract that stipulates you're owed 1000 dollars...

Normally, you'd sell that on for more than the original 100 dollars.

Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by jddj on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:46AM (#20652117)
I'd also be very interested to know whether this is also the case in the other western countries, as this is how several sketchy umbrella companies work in the UK.

For those unaware, an umbrella company acts as the "employer" of contractors for places like the NHS. It's often required (or perhaps phrased strongly enough as such by the recruiters that it's difficult for a layperson to know whether it's true) to have one, and they charge a fee + withhold income tax and national insurance contributions + pay the salary of the contractor.

The sketchy ones have determined that they can pay the contractor minimum wage + a small "loan" each month of the remainder which is promised (verbally only, of course) to be forgiven entirely, and this way charge a higher fee and remain competitive because the contractor is paying minimal tax.

Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by makomk on Friday August 09, 2019 @05:57AM (#20652825)
HRMC cracked down on that recently and sent a bunch of NHS staff bills as large as multiple years of wages, which obviously they can't afford to pay: https://www.theguardian.com/money/2019/feb/16/thousands-of-w... Basically, they they changed the rules so that the entire "loan" counted as though it was forgiven and chargable as income in one lump sum in 2019, meaning that most of it was charged at the higher rate of tax.

The astounding thing about this is that as I understand it, the nurses and doctors who're being screwed over aren't generally the ones who benefited financially from this scheme - it was the NHS (effectively the government) which did. The companies running it witheld the tax the employees should've paid but kept it and used it to fund the cost of running payroll plus their profita, meaning the NHS didn't have to pay those costs. A bunch of existing employees were forced onto the scheme in order to keep their jobs too. (There were similar schemes for wealthy individuals in other industries which did cut them in on most of the tax savings though.)

Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by jddj on Friday August 09, 2019 @07:10AM (#20653187)
Thanks for this.

On your second point, from my personal experience (we investigated the scam when it was offered to us before avoiding it based on the bad smell it gave off), my instinct would be to disagree.

When we did the calculations, we would have been hundreds of pounds per week better off under the conditions of the scam than if we had paid tax directly as a contractor or under an umbrella company who reported the full salary as a salary. I don't have much doubt that these nurses and doctors didn't benefit financially by only paying [tax and NI on minimum wage + the slightly higher umbrella fee] rather than [tax and NI on their full salary + a smaller umbrella fee]. Although that's not to say that they thought what they were doing was shady, or even that they actively chose that particular umbrella company.

I dont see the benefit to the NHS either. If the NHS pays the contractor's salary of £1000/month (under subcontract conditions) to:

- Umbrella company A, who then subtracts a fee + withholds (for HMRC) NI and tax for minimum wage before paying the contractor minimum wage + a loan of whatever remains from the £1000

and

- Umbrella company B, who subtracts a fee + withholds NI and tax for the full salary before paying the contractor the remainder

My understanding is that to the NHS both scenarios look the same (a cost to them of £1000/month), but in scenario A the contractor and umbrella company (through their ability to charge a higher fee than their competitors and still attract clientele) benefit from money which otherwise would have gone to HMRC.

Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by philjohn on Friday August 09, 2019 @05:56AM (#20652816)
The UK can, and previously has, clamped down on this kind of thing AND backdated the law as it’s classed as a clarification that they were breaking existing tax law provisions ... in some cases contractors had fines and penalties going back 20 years.

IR 35 is what a lot of these companies claim to shield you from ... but it’s notoriously complex.

Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by eloff on Friday August 09, 2019 @09:55AM (#20654307)
Good lord that's awful. You're already down, and then a stroke of good fortune lets you rise off the mat, only for the IRS to show up and smack you back down again.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by CPLX on Friday August 09, 2019 @08:09AM (#20653540)
That’s correct but the taxes are waived if you can show insolvency, which is defined via a basic worksheet as an excess of debt over assets.

For most/many of the people going through a financial crisis that caused them to default that negates the tax effect.

Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by rolltiide on Friday August 09, 2019 @01:34AM (#20651592)
Not in Canada for personal purchases
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by coldtea on Thursday August 08, 2019 @10:36PM (#20650904)
Is that the case anywhere else on the universe - besides totalitarian dystopias?
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by CamperBob2 on Thursday August 08, 2019 @10:39PM (#20650919)
This law is likely to exist because someone treated 'debt forgiveness' as a loophole for earning tax free income.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by ac29 on Thursday August 08, 2019 @11:05PM (#20651014)
Probably as a way to get around gift or estate taxes - if you can just "loan" someone money, then forgive it immediately, gift and estate taxes are trivially avoided.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by lonelappde on Friday August 09, 2019 @12:10AM (#20651284)
The gift tax exemption is higher than the amount of unsecured debt most people owe.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by ac29 on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:18AM (#20651742)
Forget about unsecured debt - if a parent wants to give their child $100,000 there is no way to do that without paying taxes (or spreading it out over many years).

If they could simply "loan" their child $100k (with no intention to ever get paid back), then forgive the debt tax-free, they'd have successfully gotten around the gift tax.

The same thing could be potentially be used by an employer: instead of paying wages, they could just "loan" (again, not intending to be paid back) their employee money, then forgive the debt tax-free.

Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by zaroth on Friday August 09, 2019 @01:08AM (#20651478)
It is now, but this was not always true.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by eigenvector on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:54AM (#20651897)
Canada has neither gift or estate taxes.
Re:'It's crazy': Chase forgiving all debt owed by its Canada... by LoSboccacc on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:56AM (#20652164)
this is an oversimplification, you still have to file capital gains, there are some exemption, so it works for debt cancellation and few other things, but it's not as straightforward as "neither gift nor estate taxes"