News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Framework for Moderation by freen on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @01:43PM (#20636988)
Are you a free speech absolutist at your own house party?

Really?

You'd allow a Nazi to spout propaganda at your family and guests?

Why should anyone else have to host them on their private platforms?

Re:A Framework for Moderation by LordHumungous on Thursday August 08, 2019 @08:15PM (#20650227)
> Why should anyone else have to host them on their private platforms?

Because it's hard to draw the line between acceptable speech and unacceptable speech, and once it becomes acceptable to silence people that power will be abused, especially if it is in the hands of large corporations. The logic is exactly the same as why the government shouldn't ban speech.

> Are you a free speech absolutist at your own house party?

My house is not a public platform so that's a silly analogy.

Re:A Framework for Moderation by umvi on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @02:16PM (#20637333)
> Why should anyone else have to host them on their private platforms?

Because private platforms are the public now.

It's like saying: "You are a Nazi I don't like your beliefs, you are not allowed to express them on my house"

So the Nazi leaves and starts preaching on the sidewalk, but the HOA comes by and says "You are a Nazi, and we don't like your beliefs. We own and maintain these sidewalks, and we are kicking you off"

So the Nazi stands in the middle of the road to preach, but the government had long since let private corporations build and maintain the roads in this neighborhood and Streets LLC comes by and says "Sorry, we own these roads and we don't like your beliefs, get out"

Thus, there is no public space for the Nazi to express his beliefs in, because all public space is now owned by private corporations.

Tying the analogy back to computers:

Even if the Nazi tries to host their own blog on their own computer in their own house, Comcast can say: "Sorry, we don't like transmitting your ideas from your house over our wires to the internet, get out"

Re:A Framework for Moderation by freen on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @05:21PM (#20639230)
The cloud is just someone else's computer.

Why do you insist on treating internet companies as if they were nation states?

Re:A Framework for Moderation by antepodius on Thursday August 08, 2019 @04:58AM (#20642879)
Once a company gets big enough, the quantitative difference in scale creates a qualitative difference. We don't let electricity providers deny service based on politics; we have a whole legal class called 'public utilities' for this. Public utility laws infringe on the freedom of utility companies, anyway.

The question is when a website/service should be classed a public utility.

Re:A Framework for Moderation by laughinghan on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @02:36PM (#20637533)
I don't see a problem here. The more people think the Nazi's speech is harmful, the smaller the Nazi's reach is. This is exactly the incentive gradient we want. You're describing the free market of ideas working excellently.