News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by rudyfink on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @12:35PM (#20636310)
Speaking as a software engineer who became an attorney, I would say that most attorneys could benefit from basic programming knowledge (e.g., simple scripts, macros, and SQL).

I say this because the bulk of work for many types of legal practice is information filtering/search/organization/and presentation, both in wrangling evidence and in exploring the law itself. Basic programming knowledge can do great magic in terms of making these processes more efficient, such as by programmatically manipulating the hundreds or millions of files that can be produced in legal cases.

In terms of more in-depth knowledge of programming, there is a definite place for it in the law (it has worked to my benefit), but I think that role is specialized/limited. I think improved software tools will, generally, fill the profession's need rather than every attorney attempting to specialize in another field enough to roll their own apps.

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by jimktrains2 on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @12:48PM (#20636431)
> I would say that most attorneys could benefit from basic programming knowledge (e.g., simple scripts, macros, and SQL).

I would argue that this is true of nearly everyone. A small amount of knowledge can go a long way in helping to build simple tools that save a lot of labour.

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by oarabbus_ on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @02:32PM (#20637480)
How was that career change? Worthwhile (from a financial, job security, level of responsibility etc sense)?
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by stult on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @06:48PM (#20640015)
I went the opposite way. Big law to programming. I make about the same (maybe slightly less but not if you account for unreimbursed business expenses like buying suits and similar hidden costs of employment) but for less work and I'm way happier. Many, possibly most, lawyers are miserable and hate their work. It's long hours and high stress, both because the stakes are usually high and you are frequently dealing with open interpersonal conflict/adversarial relationships. Plus no chance for equity, so you're an hourly worker for life.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by jandinter on Thursday August 08, 2019 @05:47AM (#20643048)
I went this way as well: Worked in big law, always enjoyed coding on the side, and went all in with coding to build an MVP for a document collaboration platform. It is an experience I wouldn't want to miss.

For anyone else who is thinking about switching careers, this is how I started: At some point during my career as a lawyer I started collecting ideas for a better, more effective way to work as a lawyer. Software could help a lot while doing many administrative tasks and would allow a lawyer to focus on what creates value - giving legal advice, thinking through tough legal problems, negotiating a great outcome for the client... Yet a lot of enterprise software is too hard to grasp, and many lawyers just stick with the old way, doing most things manually (by themselves or have it done by their assistants).

So I started building one MVP, pivoted and now am building a "GitHub for Word". Steep learning curve as a startup founder and well worth giving it a try. If you are interested, check out my project Jules: https://julesdocs.com

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by epmaybe on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @07:25PM (#20640295)
> no chance for equity

What about as a partner?

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by stult on Thursday August 08, 2019 @09:14AM (#20644177)
Law firms are usually organized as LLPs, LLCs, or PCs these days, but bottom line that means ownership shares can't be freely transferred. You can't sell your stake, so there's no opportunity for a major liquidity event like you might experience as an employee compensated in stock at a corporation when the stock increases in value dramatically and you sell.

Worse yet, lawyers have to keep working to continue to receive equity compensation in the overwhelming majority of cases. So you can't retire and continue to make money from your equity stake. You can't even really cut back on the crazy hours. This answer covers it pretty thoroughly: https://www.quora.com/Do-partners-in-law-firms-keep-a-share-...

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by oarabbus_ on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @07:42PM (#20640399)
I thought Big Law pays $200k+? Meaning that the typical programmer would be making considerably less, or is that not the case?
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by TheCoelacanth on Thursday August 08, 2019 @01:26PM (#20646503)
Someone with the drive and intelligence to make it in big law (i.e. a far above average lawyer) is probably not going to be making the salary of an average programmer.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by stult on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:07PM (#20640563)
Depends on the lawyer and the programmer. I was on the lower end of big law and I'm on the upper end of programming.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by JudgeWapner on Thursday August 08, 2019 @12:22AM (#20641832)
Biglaw pays 200k in high CoL areas where Big-N tech workers start out at 200k.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by oarabbus_ on Thursday August 08, 2019 @05:05PM (#20648757)
I work in tech in a high CoL area, and sure senior engineers and eng managers are making 200k+ total comp. SWEs with <5 years of experience are not starting out over 200k.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by rayiner on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:44PM (#20640778)
There is overlap in terms of required aptitude, but otherwise they’re completely different jobs, so it’s odd to ask whether the change is “worthwhile.” Do you like cooperation and building things? You probably won’t like being a lawyer. Do you like conflict and tactical maneuvering? You might enjoy being a lawyer. You can make a good living doing either.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by james_in_the_uk on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @02:46PM (#20637631)
I did it too. It has been successful for me but inherent conservatism of the legal profession can be wearing over time.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by petra on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @12:44PM (#20636392)
>> attorneys could benefit from basic programming knowledge (e.g., simple scripts, macros, and SQL).

Can you give a few examples of practical uses of those tools ?

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by gjstein on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @12:54PM (#20636501)
I was a paralegal a number of years back and, due to my experience as a coder, I was able to automate a bunch of my responsibilities. Much of the job of a paralegal (and some of the responsibilities of a lawyer) are things like data entry and records keeping that are trivially automated. One of my most popular tasks was to take data from Doc X in format A and move it to Doc Y in format B. Some string parsing (with human oversight) massively accelerated my productivity.

I wrote a short blurb about my experience a little while ago: http://www.cachestocaches.com/2016/2/how-we-teach-programmin...

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by stult on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @06:59PM (#20640088)
My first day at my last job as an attorney, I was told to submit 3000 files to a team of paralegals to have them manually convert them to PDF and rename them using a standard exhibit convention (eg EX-2019-001). This activity consumed three FTEs annually. I wrote a script to automate it in ten minutes.

If anyone there had even the slightest sense of how easy that would be to automate, they'd have saved hundreds of thousands of dollars by paying some random kid $200 to write them a bash script.

That's just a simple example, but I ran into issues like that on a daily basis. Databases full of evidence that were discarded because no one knew how to access them or run queries on them. Whole inboxes of emails in ost files thrown away because no one knew how to open them. Hundreds of hours spent manually reviewing documents when OCR and a decent text search tool could have gotten the same result in minutes. It was just never ending.

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by pnw_hazor on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @07:15PM (#20640211)
There are cheap PDF tools that do all that -- many designed specifically for making and marking exhibits.

Also, there are discovery production management tools that incorporate indexing, OCR, searches, and what not.

For more complicated stuff you can use vendors.

It sounds like your old firm liked to bill clients for all of that extra staff time -- keep the revenue up.

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by stult on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @07:20PM (#20640256)
This was years ago, and the commercial offerings weren't as well developed.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by SkyBelow on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @01:06PM (#20636640)
An example I was once involved in.

You have a $VeryExpensive accident.

There are $LargeNumber companies which have some partial liability.

That they are liable is extremely easy to prove, but the extent of the liability is extremely difficult and can be extremely costly on a per company bases.

You also have a database which holds most of the contributions of each of these companies, allowing you to build up a case for why each company has a certain percent of liability. While there is a team of lawyers and a team of programmers working on this case, the ability of lawyers to pull up simple enough data reduces the dependency of involving the programmers, and the lawyers having a basic understanding of SQL helps them both communicating with the programming team and when they have to explain things in front of the judge. Being able to query the data allows for the lawyers to better grasp which cases are the most worthwhile to pursue.

And for macros, sometimes you don't have a simple database, but you do have very standardized forms that are easy to scrape data off of.

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by torstenvl on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @12:59PM (#20636551)
Higher echelon (DOJ, State AG's office, etc.) wants to make a case for a change in the law and needs statistics about how many cases over the past x years where certain factors are met. You can query your case management database... or you can send an RFI to every subordinate office and make them do it by hand when they already have crazy workloads.

You have a set of documents you prepare regularly. Could be a Power of Attorney, a diversion agreement, whatever. You can highlight the frequently changed part and substitute information by hand... or you can set up a macro with a form to enter the information and have it automatically generate.

Attorneys are knowledge workers burdened with a lot of administrative nonsense. There is a lot of low hanging fruit for automation.

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by gamblor956 on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @01:27PM (#20636873)
You have a set of documents you prepare regularly. Could be a Power of Attorney, a diversion agreement, whatever. You can highlight the frequently changed part and substitute information by hand... or you can set up a macro with a form to enter the information and have it automatically generate.

Law firms have been using software to do this for 2 decades. Rather than using macros, they have dedicated document-management systems that can generate templates/documents based on the type of filing, client, etc. that get further customized by lawyers as needed.

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by torstenvl on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @01:47PM (#20637029)
Some of them do this. Some of them don't. We used to have LexisNexis HotDocs. Now we don't. However, even if we still had a third-party macro and templating system that was better-suited to the task, it would still be useful for the lawyers to know how to program those macros.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by rudyfink on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @01:09PM (#20636672)
One simple example would be where an attorney receives a thumb-drive with 100s of documents and files as a "production" in a case. An attorney without basic skills would (or would have staff) manually enter all of those files into a spreadsheet or a word document. An attorney with basic programming skills would write/run a short shell script that instantly pumps all of the metadata about those files into an Excel spreadsheet.

Another example, though a bit more general, would be an attorney trying to find documents in a case that were created around a certain date. An attorney without basic skills is, again, going to end up in a manual or semi-manual (with a basic tool) process. An attorney with basic programming skills is likely able to directly craft a query that produces the documents.

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by rayiner on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @01:22PM (#20636809)
Or you send it to a vendor who has written the code to do that.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by pnw_hazor on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @03:26PM (#20637998)
This.

It doesn't make much sense for a $400/hr attorney to play around with scripts and such or otherwise do much of anything with document production (that is what staff is for).

If an attorney knows coding from a previous career, it can be helpful in a few cases, but for a non-technical attorney to try to pick up enough coding to do anything useful is a stretch.

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by RichEO on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @05:42PM (#20639451)
It may be the case that some vendor somewhere can provide a tool to do this, but they will charge quite a bit more than $400 and it will take more than an hour to find them.

A shell script to achieve your ends could be endlessly helpful here.

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by pnw_hazor on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @07:08PM (#20640154)
Having the depth of knowledge to recognize when a simple shell script would be helpful is the harder part.

It is one thing to teach a non-techie lawyer how to "hello world" But getting them to understand file system attributes, permission schemes, file I/O, regular expressions, and so on, is where "learn to code" falls apart in this context.

Just getting a non-technical person to learn how to navigate in Powershell is a near impossibility.

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by azernik on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @04:14PM (#20638443)
That comes with long RTTs and delays. That's often how Big Law does things, but it's suboptimal in lots of cases.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by rayiner on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @04:18PM (#20638485)
My vendors are pretty responsive (hours for a small production). They're using the same automated scripts 'rudyfink is talking about--they're just already written, tested, and ready-to-go.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by ohaideredevs on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @12:49PM (#20636447)
Would you say a lawyer can make more / be more employable than the average lawyer if they can take software-related cases?
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by rudyfink on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @01:19PM (#20636775)
That is more complicated than you might think. In a lot of ways the legal profession is only a semi-functioning market--at least compared to software. On one hand, there are fairly amazing and very longstanding restrictions on how attorneys can market their services. This makes it harder (or outright impossible) for an attorney to market, so that diminishes (but does not eliminate) comparative technical advantage. On the other hand, salaries for most starting attorneys (i.e, associates) are fixed nationwide and proceed, generally, in lockstep, so almost all firms will pay the same, regardless of technical skill. So, the attorney is likely more "employable," but the market signals are substantially muted.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by gamblor956 on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @01:36PM (#20636933)
On the other hand, salaries for most starting attorneys (i.e, associates) are fixed nationwide and proceed, generally, in lockstep, so almost all firms will pay the same, regardless of technical skill.

This is not true at all. Salaries for starting lawyers at "BigLaw" firms are generally fixed...but only by firm and by location. So Firm A in NYC pays $XXXk but their LA office only pays $YYYk. Firm B probably pays close to $XXXk in NYC but might pay $ZZZk. And if you go down to the smaller firms, they could pay anywhere from $40k to $XXXk based on location, type of law, etc.

After the first year, very few firms are lockstep with regards to raises...in the past few years, I think only 1 or 2 major firms is still on the lockstep model. Raises after 2nd year are almost universally based on performance, which depends heavily on technical skill (technical meaning legal, not programming, skills).

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by vqc on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @05:36PM (#20639392)
Are you sure this is true?

It seems -to-edit many more than one or two of this hundred https://www.vault.com/best-companies-to-work-for/law/top-100... are still paying lockstep.

Cravath still lists lockstep raises for years 1-7. Skadden years 1-8. Latham 1-9. Davis Polk 1-6. Etc. Are the firms reporting one thing but actually doing something else?

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by gamblor956 on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @06:25PM (#20639855)
With respect to the BigLaw firms cited, yes, since Cravath is the only one that is actually doing lockstep.

They rest don't do lockstep anymore. On paper they start with lockstep, but actual raises are based on performance, location, legal group, etc. I have enough friends at Skadden and Latham in different offices to confirm that.

Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by vqc on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @09:11PM (#20640943)
I've never heard of anyone who hit their billable minimums (e.g. 1900, 2k, etc) not get bumped to the next year. Although I guess there's a bit of a dance that happens years 5/7-9 for people who think they have a shot at partner.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by joshAg on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @01:26PM (#20636850)
Doesn't the lockstep go away after only a promotion or two when the attorneys get promoted beyond senior associate? I guess that's still the better part of a decade, though.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by james_in_the_uk on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @02:52PM (#20637685)
The promotions are based on business case, especially as you get senior. To make a business case for partnership practicing technology law at BigLaw you need to have a decade or more of doing that as an associate, where you get paid more or less the same as everyone else at your level. In fact it can be harder to meet your targets / make your bonuses because technology law tends to be faster moving than other areas so proportionally more time needs to be spent on professional developer, as against fee earning.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by ohaideredevs on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @03:55PM (#20638243)
Interesting, thanks. I always wondered if there is carry over to law if you know say, finance or SE well.
Re:Should lawyers learn to code? Arguments for and against by pnw_hazor on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @03:34PM (#20638073)
No. While a lawyer can build a lucrative practice around software/tech clients, the legal issues are not really unique to software. Learning to recognize/handle legal issues common to tech companies does not require programming skills.

Though, an exception would be patent attorneys. Patent attorneys with CS/EE degrees are usually in high demand.