News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:8chan's new provider BitMitigate goes offline by ThrustVectoring on Tuesday August 06, 2019 @03:05PM (#20628401)
There's more factors in play, too. It's coherent to think B && !A, but also (C) Unelected members of the press should not have the power to shame businesses into excluding individuals and organizations.
Re:8chan's new provider BitMitigate goes offline by FDSGSG on Tuesday August 06, 2019 @07:30PM (#20630701)
What about just me? I'm not a member of the press.

Should I not have the power to shame businesses into excluding individuals and organizations?

Perhaps they're doing something they should be ashamed of.

Re:8chan's new provider BitMitigate goes offline by ThrustVectoring on Tuesday August 06, 2019 @10:19PM (#20631474)
No, you shouldn't have that power. Doing business with someone and providing services to them isn't and shouldn't be an endorsement of their values. Jeffrey Epstein should be able to hire whatever legal council he wants, convicted sex offenders should be able to find an apartment upon release, gun stores should be able to take credit card payments, and generally speaking you shouldn't get excluded from the benefits of modern society simply for being unpopular, no matter how just the reasoning.
Re:8chan's new provider BitMitigate goes offline by FDSGSG on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @07:40AM (#20633753)
So, in other words: Freedom of association should not exist.

Am I getting this right?

Re:8chan's new provider BitMitigate goes offline by ThrustVectoring on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @01:34PM (#20636927)
Not at all. I'm not complaining about Cloudflare or Voxility dropping customers. I'm complaining about the press using their influence to pressure those companies into dropping customers.

You're still free to drop a customer for whatever reason. I just want the press to be held accountable for the torts they're committing and the economic harm they are causing.

Re:8chan's new provider BitMitigate goes offline by FDSGSG on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @07:24PM (#20640288)
Ah, so freedom of association is OK. Freedom of speech is not though?

> press using their influence to pressure those companies into dropping customers

So what does that even look like? Odds are it looks like this:

"Hey, I'm working on a story about 8chan and heard you guys host them. Do you have anything to say about that?"

I guess what you're saying is that the press should just not be allowed to report on this stuff.

>torts they're committing

such as? IANAL, but the first amendment provides strong protections against tortious interference claims.

Re:8chan's new provider BitMitigate goes offline by ThrustVectoring on Thursday August 08, 2019 @04:53AM (#20642859)
I'm not a free speech absolutist. If you cause certain established categories of harm, you should be held liable for the damages you cause.

Specific example: https://mobile.twitter.com/alexstamos/status/115839279568757...

BitMitigate has a case for tortious interference over this tweet, IMO. Alex knew of contracts between BitMitigate and 8chan (or Voxility), used his influence to induce Voxility to make it impossible for BitMitigate to fulfill their 8chan contract (or for the breach of their voxility contract), Alex was not privileged to interfere, and there were economic damages suffered. That's all the elements necessary for a tortious interference with contract claim.

>IANAL, but the first amendment provides strong protections against tortious interference claims.

Indeed it does. Generally, merely sharing truthful information does not provide a basis for tortious interference. The problem I have isn't that these sorts of statements are false, but that they come attached with a threat of an active negative PR campaign. The format of twitter makes this particularly salient, since it makes it easy to get viral traction and hard to communicate extensive information. And the tweet I linked earlier didn't tell Voxility anything it didn't already know, it simply publicized things and used the author's influence coercively.

Re:8chan's new provider BitMitigate goes offline by FDSGSG on Thursday August 08, 2019 @03:01PM (#20647479)
>threat of an active negative PR campaign

I'm sorry, but this doesn't feel like an accurate characterisation. Stamos isn't financing or organising an actual PR campaign, he's just publicly telling the truth.

If the truth happens to be outrageous, that's not his fault.

>And the tweet I linked earlier didn't tell Voxility anything it didn't already know

Dunno, Voxility is huge.

>it simply publicized things and used the author's influence coercively.

If the truth is coercive, perhaps that's not on the author?

Re:8chan's new provider BitMitigate goes offline by ThrustVectoring on Thursday August 08, 2019 @04:54PM (#20648625)
It absolutely is organizing and advocating a campaign: https://mobile.twitter.com/alexstamos/status/115802918989673...

>If the truth is coercive, perhaps that's not on the author?

You're ignoring the context. Blue check with 50k followers who has testified to congress on tech matters, multiple followup tweets @voxility by others, and intense media scrutiny of 8chan and their business partners following the El Paso shooting. The exact same tweet made as a DM would not have anywhere near the pressure as what they did. The publicity itself is pressure; this is why corporate twitter accounts try to take your tweeted complaints into DMs as soon as possible.

Re:8chan's new provider BitMitigate goes offline by reilly3000 on Tuesday August 06, 2019 @10:17PM (#20631468)
One doesn’t elect employees of a private business. They choose not to consume media that business produces. Do you think that we should elect people to tell us what’s happening?
Re:8chan's new provider BitMitigate goes offline by ThrustVectoring on Tuesday August 06, 2019 @10:21PM (#20631489)
No, I'm saying that people generally should not use their influence with third parties to enact extrajudicial punishment. Tortious interference with contract is a bad thing.
Re:8chan's new provider BitMitigate goes offline by reilly3000 on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @12:40PM (#20636354)
So long as the WWW is a public network ran by private entities, essentially every decision is extrajudicial. I completely see the issue you're trying to highlight, but it seems that limiting the abilities of reporters and activists isn't healthy for democracy. If the services CloudFlare and others provide is regulated like a public utility, then standards like guaranteeing equal access regardless of ideology, or enforcing standards that have been democratically adopted. Is there a middle ground between regulation and corporate discretion in all matters of speech on that use their platform?