If the company is profitable and its value is growing against inflation (slow growth), then it's worth having a share in it even if it's not paying dividends. (It's actually hard to find something solid that grows against inflation, in the long term).
>If the company's return on borrowed money is higher than the interest rate it pays on that borrowed money, paying down the loan would be a waste of money.
The company's 'returns' on paying dividends is actually negative, all other things equal.
>Now consider another scenario: rather than the shop opening up a new branch, what if the investors (i.e. the owners) want to invest in a different or new business, with potential for higher returns in the future?
If the investors really think they're not getting their money's worth (i.e. the separate assets are worth more or the management is bad), then it makes sense to initiate a takeover.
P.S. please downvote after you have heard a reply.
> I'd say that if a company has extra cash, it is better off paying its long term debts rather than dishing it out to the shareholders.
That kind of blanket statement makes absolutely zero sense to me, and surely if you thought about it for more than 5 seconds, you too can see how silly it is. If the company's return on borrowed money is higher than the interest rate it pays on that borrowed money, paying down the loan would be a waste of money.
Consider a large shop that has a mortgage on its premises. Is it best for it to invest all its profits in paying down its mortgage? Or should it open up a new branch elsewhere instead, borrowing the money for the premises, on the basis that its business model has been proven to have profit that exceeds the cost of finance? Which would make more money? Now consider another scenario: rather than the shop opening up a new branch, what if the investors (i.e. the owners) want to invest in a different or new business, with potential for higher returns in the future?