News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Lisp is a Big Hack (And Haskell is Doomed to Succeed) by pwpwp on Monday January 03, 2011 @03:17AM (#2062571)
Good point - I forgot to consider this approach. I'll have come back to it at another point.

Generally though, I think Haskell's approach of re-adding freedoms is more fruitful than trying to add bondage to Lisp. And "the Haskell movement" certainly has a different kind of manpower behind it.

Re:Why Lisp is a Big Hack (And Haskell is Doomed to Succeed) by kunjaan on Monday January 03, 2011 @03:37AM (#2062599)
>And "the Haskell movement" certainly has a different kind of manpower behind it.

Can you clarify what you mean by the words "movement" and "different kind of manpower"?

How is progress in languages like Racket different from Haskell?

Why do you think that adding "interesting" type systems in Lisp would be "heroic" and less "fruitful"?

Re:Why Lisp is a Big Hack (And Haskell is Doomed to Succeed) by pwpwp on Monday January 03, 2011 @03:46AM (#2062609)
There are probably hundreds, if not thousands of researchers, who use Haskell (and related PLs) as their vehicle for type system research. People working on "gradual" type systems like Typed Racket are probably around a dozen, which means that progress in Haskell happens much faster and with more breadth.
Re:Why Lisp is a Big Hack (And Haskell is Doomed to Succeed) by Raphael_Amiard on Monday January 03, 2011 @05:30AM (#2062754)
While i think you make valid points, i do not agree with the conclusion.

First, i don't think associating innovativity with numbers of researchers is a safe predicate since it's clearly not linear.

Second, the fact that haskell is a testbed for researchers doesn't make it the ideal language for "real world programming" in my opinion. It could be that it is, but again the correlation is less than clear.

And third, and that's the most important point in my opinion, the ideas developped in haskell are fully available to other language implementors once they exist, and the experience of researchers is available. It means that a language like typed racket or any other could possibly implement the best/most usefull of those ideas in much less time than was needed to first find them.

Re:Why Lisp is a Big Hack (And Haskell is Doomed to Succeed) by thesz on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @01:23PM (#2067906)
>Second, the fact that haskell is a testbed for researchers doesn't make it the ideal language for "real world programming" in my opinion.

Once upon a time Lisp was a language for researchers.

Re:Why Lisp is a Big Hack (And Haskell is Doomed to Succeed) by kunjaan on Tuesday January 04, 2011 @05:48PM (#2068887)
It still is.
Re:Why Lisp is a Big Hack (And Haskell is Doomed to Succeed) by jneira on Monday January 03, 2011 @04:22AM (#2062666)
and what about http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qi_%28programming_language%29 (via @fogus)?? Choose haskell as the only way to programming nirvana could be eliminate other differents points of view. In fact choose whatever will do
Re:Why Lisp is a Big Hack (And Haskell is Doomed to Succeed) by thesz on Monday January 03, 2011 @08:12AM (#2063021)
When my post started a heated conversation in ru_lisp LiveJournal community, someone told there about his personal experience with Qi. He managed to convince Qi that 42 is of type String.

That's the price of freedom of Lisp.