Re:Europe is edging towards making post-car cities a reality
by goodcanadian on Tuesday August 06, 2019 @05:59AM
(#20623776)
Density would rapidly increase around stations if planning allowed for it. See all along the Skytrain in the Greater Vancouver area (British Columbia). For people in between or away from stations, you need good integration with the bus network. Anywhere where there is enough traffic to cause congestion has enough traffic to support good public transit which definitely covers most of LA.
Re:Europe is edging towards making post-car cities a reality
by vladojsem on Tuesday August 06, 2019 @05:16AM
(#20623563)
I agree with you. In the case of LA metro area, it is just too spread city = badly designed.
If you imagine even fast public transport, to get from one side of LA to the other side, it would still require a lot of stops in the low population density areas. Let's say every stop would cost you 5 minutes which means that even a car could be faster than public transport.
Re:Europe is edging towards making post-car cities a reality
by goodcanadian on Tuesday August 06, 2019 @06:03AM
(#20623792)
There is no way every stop costs you 5 minutes, more like 1 minute. I am not a fan of buses because they are in the same traffic as cars plus they have to stop as you say. There are some mitigations like dedicated bus lanes that can swing the speed equation back in favour of buses. What you really want, however, is feeder buses taking people to the train, and it is easy to design a rail system that beats cars for speed in a city (basically any urban rail I've ever seen).
Re:Europe is edging towards making post-car cities a reality
by vladojsem on Tuesday August 06, 2019 @06:34AM
(#20623930)
1 minute with the vehicle slowing down and speeding up again? If it is bus it goes to the bus stop, other cars have to allow it to go back to the main road.
Edit: 5 minutes would be way too much if I think about it again - you are right.
Re:Europe is edging towards making post-car cities a reality
by nickez on Tuesday August 06, 2019 @07:28AM
(#20624180)
You don't have to allow cars to go on the same lanes as buses. In Europe it is very common with separate bus lanes.
Why do trains work well in many European countries? When there's farmland between stations (or even between some bus stops in the city where I currently live), it means that because you normally want to go somewhere that's not farmland, you're very likely to want to go somewhere near a station. The density around specific points (train stations, bus/tram plazas, etc.) is particularly high which makes the last-mile or last-kilometer problem largely a non-issue.
If you build this in the LA metro area, it might serve the people who live very close to stations well, but everyone else who lives somewhere in the middle between two stations (which would be a higher percentage than people living in European farmland) would need to find a way to get home from the station.