> The US government actually spends more per capita on healthcare($4,197/person/year) than most countries with free excellent healthcare (Switzerland $4178/pp/y, Canada $3074/pp/y, UK $2802/pp/y). Netherlands govt spends barely more than the US govt at $4495/pp/y.
This is an unbelievably important thing to bring up. The US government already spends enough to have fully socialized, excellent health care. The only reason taxes have to go up for an M4A proposal is because enormous amounts of protectionist legislation and regulatory capture make the same services cost double in the US. If we had sane health care costs (which could be accomplished pretty quickly by opening the local market to foreign competition), taxes wouldn't have to go up at all.
edit: Dean Baker made a suggestion that stuck with me years ago; instead of a public option, just allow Americans to buy into other countries' health systems, for example, France's. They could provide services at a nice rate on US soil, and use US payments and addition to the risk pool to subsidize their own citizens' health care at home. Other countries would start competing with each other for US business, and would so radically undercut local providers that health care prices would be vaguely economically justifiable in no time.
One problem is if this is opt in, only the elderly and sick will want to buy in and the foreign government would balk at the large number of high risk signups. Young and healthy individuals who are accustomed to the freedom of not buying insurance and just going to the emergency room will be reluctant to pay for something that they believe they don’t want. There’s also a mismatch between therapies permitted by the FDA, religious freedom laws, etc.
All these things really need to happen to close a lot of the loopholes in the US system.
The Netherlands income tax is also marginal but the 51.75% rate kicks in at €68,507, and the lowest rates are already over 30%.
When you get to this point I think it's ,more useful to look at what proportion of a countries GDP is taken in by the government.
Property tax rates are in the single digits (or very rarely, the low double digits). And only apply to property owners.
Payroll taxes are distinct from income taxes but reduce taxable income so shouldn't be split out separately...
So, TLDR: you'd still need to be making more than $300k+ each year for your annual total tax % (all inclusive) to exceed 50%. That puts you in the 0.1% of Americans.
555 of them took the standard deduction instead of itemizing!
https://www.irs.gov/statistics/soi-tax-stats-individual-stat...
Source: Trump's tax returns.
Actual source: https://www.nytimes.com/2011/08/15/opinion/stop-coddling-the...
One source (there are many others with like 20 seconds of google searching): https://www.wsj.com/articles/top-20-of-americans-will-pay-87...
The US government actually spends more per capita on healthcare($4,197/person/year) than most countries with free excellent healthcare (Switzerland $4178/pp/y, Canada $3074/pp/y, UK $2802/pp/y). Netherlands govt spends barely more than the US govt at $4495/pp/y.
https://www.visualcapitalist.com/u-s-spends-public-money-hea...