News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by nkurz on Sunday January 02, 2011 @02:08PM (#2060720)
This is a brilliant graph, but I don't think you are reading Taubes' article correctly. He is not offering "straightforward calculations", rather he is setting up a "straw man" ("Aunt Sally") which he feels represents the "almost incomprehensibly naïve and wrong-headed" conventional wisdom. Like you, Taubes does not believe that 20 calories a day is a good way to represent the difference between an obese and non-obese individual.

While it's obvious from the response here on HN that he fails to make this clear, he's setting up a contrafactual argument. He's lamenting that even the best science writers we have (like Jonah Lehrer) seem to offer only simplistic truisms like the 20 calories myth. You point out (correctly) that 20 calories is misleading by using a brilliant graph. Taubes attempts (and apparently fails) to bring it down with logic and rhetoric.

Now, it's true that Taubes wouldn't fully agree with your graph. He believes that 'calories' themselves are a faulty way of viewing the world, and that the composition of the food matters more than the calculated calories. He believes it matters whether that 450 additional calories are corn syrup or lean steak. But at base, you are not disagreeing with him, and your (wonderful and to the point) graph is not contradicting anything he's saying.

I'm just finding it now, but the blog post refers to a chapter in his book: http://books.google.com/books?id=Pm9ZcFYtLZ4C&pg=PT68... Perhaps that will be a clearer exposition of his beliefs?

Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by jls11 on Sunday January 02, 2011 @02:26PM (#2060763)
I've heard this one before. "Taubes's argument is more complex than that. You need to spend more hours studying those pages, and read books x, y, and z." It's the same argument they give in college English classes for deconstructionism and all that other nonsense.

Taubes is a journalist. The people on HN are several standard deviations ahead of his audience. If he's doing his job shouldn't we all be able to understand him without any trouble? Here's a simpler argument: Taubes is wrong, and that's where the problem is.

Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by nkurz on Sunday January 02, 2011 @02:54PM (#2060826)
Taubes is a journalist.

Well, sort of. He also has an undergrad degree in Physics from Harvard and masters in Engineering from Stanford. Which doesn't mean he's right, but it does make him better qualified as a science journalist than most.

The people on HN are several standard deviations ahead of his audience.

Yes, and this is what's making me want to cry. This is one of the few audiences that knows what 'reductio ad absurdum' means, and yet bright people (whom I respect) seem unable to grasp what to me seems to me a fairly obvious argument. Are contrafactuals truly so rare as to be unrecognizable?

Ignoring the fact that his science is wrong.

Sure, it might be, but the commentary so far has not been about "his science" but about his portrayal of conventional wisdom, which he also agrees is wrong. It's like pointing out that a mathematician is obviously a fool for saying "Let us assume momentarily that the square root of two is a rational number" as the preamble to a proof.

It feels like a scene from Idiocracy. It's not that Taubes is wrong, it's that you are misreading his argument. I'm not arguing that "it's complex" --- although I'll happily stand up to defend deconstructionism --- rather I'm trying to tell you that you are in agreement with Taubes that the conventional wisdom is rubbish.

Now, if you want to point out the flaws in his actual argument and say that there is no difference between calories from carbs and from proteins, please do! But insisting that he's wrong because it really takes more than 20 calories sounds an awful lot like chanting "Brawndo's got electrolytes".

It's a new year. I want to regain my faith in the world. Please stop making me cry.

Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 02, 2011 @03:04PM (#2060850)
This is one of the few audiences that knows what 'reductio ad absurdum' means, and yet bright people (whom I respect) seem unable to grasp what to me seems to me a fairly obvious argument.

The problem is that his reducto ad absurdum isn't that absurd. It only sounds that way because he spends 3000 words ignoring 90-95% of the actual argument (specifically, 171 calories out of 191 in year 10).

The full argument: 7.5 strips of bacon/day will make you fat (technically fewer strips in earlier years, but you get the picture). 7 strips will maintain your current level of obesity, the extra 0.5 strips will allow you to gain an extra 2 lbs.

The argument as present by Taubes: only 0.5 strips of bacon in excess of maintenance is enough to explain the difference between an obese person? That's ridiculous!

Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by nkurz on Sunday January 02, 2011 @03:37PM (#2060947)
Both of these are fair questions: is Taubes accurately portraying the conventional wisdom, and what difference in diet corresponds to what final weight maintained?

Yes, Taubes is presenting a very weak version of the argument. But I think he does this for good reason: it's the camel's nose in the tent, it's the NRA's (legitimate?) fear about reasonable gun control laws. Once he can show that the simple version can be questioned, he opens room for further questioning. And I don't think that his portrayal of conventional wisdom is that far off: we have entire industries based on shaving off a few calories from our desserts, and many people seem to believe that if the fat slobs would just park at the far end of the parking lot and walk another 100 feet they wouldn't be fat.

He doesn't present the version you offer because he doesn't believe it. You're presuming that its possible to eat an additional half a slice of bacon a day and have no other effects other than maintaining a stable weight of 2 lbs greater after a year. You're also presuming that this effect would be achieved by eating an additional sugar cube. Traditional calorie counting would also imply that you'd be in the same place if instead of the bacon or sugar cube every morning that you ate an entire 7200 calories pecan pie once a year at Thanksgiving.

Taubes says this is also wrong: bacon and sugar are metabolized differently, and will have different effects on your body. Both will also have side effects on appetite and energy level. How sure are you that they are the same? How sure are you that timing doesn't make a difference? How would you design a solution to obesity that is more effective than merely encouraging people to eat a little bit less and to exercise a little bit more?

I think these are good questions, and still open to discussion. Likely there are better approaches than Taubes', but I think he's a bright guy on the right path. At the least, I think it's worth attacking his actual thesis rather than complaining that his straw man doesn't fight back as strongly as it should.

Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 02, 2011 @06:43PM (#2061501)
Once he can show that the simple version can be questioned, he opens room for further questioning.

If you want to call the simple version of a theory into question, present the simple version of the theory. Don't obscure 90% of it. Taubes doesn't present the version I described because the version I described is pretty hard to question. Has Taubes shown us that we need to question the theory that 7.5 extra strips of bacon each day will make you fat?

Also, no one believes that traditional calorie counting is perfect. It's a good first approximation, but there are corrections to be made. You've identified one - you can't absorb 7200 calories in a single day. But then again, I never heard anyone in the nutritional mainstream claim that Thanksgiving dinner is what is making America fat. They just make claims like, for example, 7.5 strips of bacon/day might make you fat, and 7.0 strips of bacon will keep you fat but not make you fatter. (Substitute cookies for bacon if you want.) There are others, many of which are already well known. Pick up any sports medicine book to learn all about them.

As for "designing a solution to obesity", we already have the solution for the vast majority of people: eat less and exercise more. Taubes is trying to sell books by misleading people about the theory underlying that solution (i.e., ignoring 90% of it). It's hard to see how that is helping us get to a better solution than what we have now.

And I don't think that his portrayal of conventional wisdom is that far off: we have entire industries based on shaving off a few calories from our desserts, and many people seem to believe that if the fat slobs would just park at the far end of the parking lot and walk another 100 feet they wouldn't be fat.

You seem to be confusing mainstream nutrition science with people hawking their own wares. Modern medical science, in the form of an about.com calculator, says that you burn about 2 calories by walking 100 feet.

http://walking.about.com/library/cal/uccalc1.htm

It might not be exactly right - maybe it's 1.5, maybe it's 2.5. But it's a good first approximation, and so is calorie counting.

Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by nkurz on Monday January 03, 2011 @12:18AM (#2062194)
But then again, I never heard anyone in the nutritional mainstream claim that Thanksgiving dinner is what is making America fat.

Well, it is the opening sentence of the Jonah Lehrer piece which Taubes is critiquing:

"Thanksgiving has always been a day of delicious gluttony. According to the American Council on Exercise, the average adult consumes nearly 4,500 calories at the Thanksgiving table, which is about twice the recommended daily intake."

This, following immediately after the title "The Real Culprit in Overeating" could cause the impression that Lehrer (one of the best science journalists out there) is claiming that Thanksgiving dinner is what is making America fat.

You seem to be confusing mainstream nutrition science with people hawking their own wares.

I don't think so, although I will request a certain artistic license. I was thinking primarily of the signs up in my local Kaiser health facility encouraging people to take the stairs (rather than the elevator) in the parking garage. Mind you, I do take the stairs, and think it's a good thing. But like Taubes (who looks quite fit and trim in his publicity photos), I'm not sure this is an adequate solution to a national health crisis. Or at the least, I'm concerned that this solution is not currently working that well.

Overall, I think you're selling Taubes a bit short. If he's a hack flogging his books for sake of nothing but sales, he's at least got a better basis than most. Time will tell, of course, but I'm betting that in the end he wins the calorie counting argument, and the idea of counting all calories as equal regardless of source won't last.

Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by yummyfajitas on Monday January 03, 2011 @07:55AM (#2062975)
From Lehrer's article: "Why do we overeat? This isn't just a problem on Thanksgiving, of course: More than a third of Americans are obese, which means that we eat way too much every day."

Regardless, Taubes wasn't pointing out that calorie counting fails on a once a year gorging incident, he was discussing a daily increase in intake. Calorie counting works pretty well for such things.

Time will tell, of course, but I'm betting that in the end he wins the calorie counting argument, and the idea of counting all calories as equal regardless of source won't last.

If that's all he is arguing, then he is doing nothing but pushing mainstream nutrition science. But if that were what he is doing, why mislead people about what calorie counting actually claims? Why not show the actual claims of calorie counting, and then show how they can be 10-20% off in some cases?

By the way, every single sports medicine textbook already does this.