News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by jerf on Sunday January 02, 2011 @01:48PM (#2060683)
That doesn't counter his point at all. The difference between "obesity" and "maintaining weight" is still implausibly thin; what Gary was talking about in the first place was the delta in the top two lines, not the net total. He mentions that more obese people eventually do reach an energy balance, which obviously happens because they income and outflow eventually balance, which is a sign that he understands that. (Sixth paragraph, starts with "First, obese people tend to be weight stable for long periods of their life".) You didn't disprove his argument, you just reiterated bits of it, only with less comprehension and a math simulation disconnected from what actually happens (your simulation lacks the relative stability that people reach and simulates the clearly false scenario in which people become fatter without bound). ("relative stability" - there is a long-term weight gain over pretty much everybody's life but when people become obese they can do so much more rapidly than ~1lb/year)

(Personally I'd break it down to the individual meals since that's where satiety occurs and now we're talking about a delta of 3 or 4 calories. It's an absurd argument. Nothing is that precise without a feedback loop. And if a feedback loop is involved, the idea that the feedback loop is what is broken is hardly that odd an idea.)

I'm seeing a lot more people declare that Taubes is wrong or obviously a crank that there are people actually demonstrating a comprehension of his points, which I tend to consider a prerequisite for an actually-effective "debunking". Maybe he's wrong, but it's not because of people arguing against points he's not even making while blatently missing the ones he is.

Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by jls11 on Sunday January 02, 2011 @02:22PM (#2060752)
Again, this is not a scientific phenomenon, it's a social phenomenon. If this was about science it would be over and done. You read his article and find it correct, I read his article and find it scientifically false. Taubes gets paid to write whatever he thinks people will latch on to. Unfortunately I don't get paid to overcome what he's obviously found to be powerful social hooks in people.

Taubes didn't sit in his study reading a "century's worth of literature" over the last decade and somehow unravel all the conventional wisdom of science with his theorizing. My personal theory, after reading his work, is that he spent much of that decade coming up with ideas to sell books. He hasn't made any advances in science. He's another Tim Ferriss/Seth Godin/Malcolm Gladwell, and if this case is anything like the past few, he'll enjoy some intellectual success and then two years later many of the slowpokes will recognize that what he's selling is enticing but not really correct.

I'm not sure what the social hooks are. Someone else suggested that smart fat people are looking for alternative explanations like in any other diet fad. I don't know if that's true, but that would explain a lot. Certainly some people are defending him purely on intellectual grounds as another intellectual defying authority, they want him to succeed. I'm glad you enjoy reading him, but, basically, he doesn't know what he's talking about.

Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by jerf on Monday January 03, 2011 @03:25PM (#2064541)
So what's your excuse for this guy: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM ? PhD in the relevant field, plus actual field experience. Or the not insignificant number of other people with actual PhDs coming to very similar conclusions? (They may seem superficially different but if you take the time to understand them both Dr. Lustig and Taubes basically have the same points.)
Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 02, 2011 @02:01PM (#2060702)
(your simulation lacks the stability that people reach and simulates the clearly false scenario in which people become fatter without bound)

True. All I did was graph the exact scenario Taubes himself described. If it is unrealistic, take it up with him.

The only difference is that I didn't "forget" to mention the 7 strips of bacon the obese person consumes in excess of the thin person.

Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by neild on Sunday January 02, 2011 @02:28PM (#2060768)
What you appear to be aggressively declining to understand, despite two prior commenters clearly explaining it--including the one that you're responding to here--is that Taubes does not argue that 20 extra calories a day makes a person fat. He argues the precise opposite, in fact, at great length and in some detail.
Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 02, 2011 @02:54PM (#2060832)
What you appear to be aggressively declining to understand is that I'm arguing that Taube's straw man is misleading. I'm not claiming his main thesis is wrong, I couldn't even figure out from the blog post what that thesis is.

He used a misleading straw man: "Look, modern medical science says only 20 cals a day makes you obese! I'll repeat 20 cals/day many times, and tell you it's just a couple of gulps of beer. I'll never mention the other 100-350 cals/day (depending on year) once in 3000 words. Only 20 cals/day must be wrong, go read my book to learn the truth! Now for a made up dialogue between myself and a personified straw man!"

Yes, technically he made no untrue claims. He just deliberately failed to mention that the straw man has a good point: 7.5 sticks of bacon/day will make you fat while 7.0 sticks of bacon will only keep you fat once you are already fat.

Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by billjings on Sunday January 02, 2011 @02:43PM (#2060804)
Ahh, if only I were at a real keyboard. I'll just say that 1) you make a fantastic point in the discussion, 2)there is evidence that even when the fat person fails to eat that additional bacon, metabolism and activity levels drop to compensate, and 3) you have failed to refute Taubes' primary point, which is that "we get fat because we eat more calories than we expend" does not satisfactorily explain why we maintain a calorie surplus in the first place.
Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 02, 2011 @03:29PM (#2060930)
Taubes' primary point, which is that "we get fat because we eat more calories than we expend" does not satisfactorily explain why we maintain a calorie surplus in the first place.

Is that really his point? That's true, but tautological.

Similarly, the theory that "the apple I dropped falls because of gravity" also doesn't explain why I dropped the apple. All it explains is how (and not why) the apple falls.

Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by billjings on Sunday January 02, 2011 @04:51PM (#2061184)
Exactly. Every search for truth must have some aim. In the case of the apple, saying "everything falls down" doesn't get at what newton was really interested in, which was the laws of motion in general. In this case, it is silly to stop at the second law of thermodynamics when you're really interested in homeostasis in the human body.
Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 02, 2011 @09:07PM (#2061815)
...saying "everything falls down" doesn't get at what newton was really interested in,...

I know it's tangential, but this is precisely what Newton was interested in. The entire point of Newtonian gravity is that everything (including the moon and other celestial bodies) falls down in exactly the same way.

(Before this, you had one set of rules for celestial bodies, another for apples.)

Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by billjings on Monday January 03, 2011 @12:03PM (#2063759)
My apologies for not being precise enough. "Everything falls down" fails as an explanation for Newton's purposes because "down" and "falls" as we use those terms on earth don't apply to stars. As a description of a phenomena, though, it points right at what Newton was interested in, as you say.

Something similar would apply here to the statement, "People are getting fat because they are overeating." As an explanation, it falls short for someone who wants to know why they overeat, but their neighbor does not.

Re:"Inanity of Overeating" ignores the bacon in the room by jerf on Monday January 03, 2011 @02:00PM (#2064225)
That's my point. You are not simulating Taubes' point. You are simulating something strictly simpler and completely different. He makes an argument based around a feedback mechanism and your model completely lacks a feedback mechanism. (You and quite a few others, really.) You (all) have skipped the step where you engage with the subject and actually listen to what is being said before you cut straight to trying to disprove it.

How do you expect to convince me or anybody else of anything with that approach? I am happy to listen to arguments against his point, but you're the one building the strawmen here.