Re:Minimizing Defection Might Be the Solution to the Tragedy...
by burtonator on Saturday August 03, 2019 @06:21PM
(#20603091)
I think the dichotomy between collusion and cooperation is a good one.
I've been thinking about the Hong Kong protests a lot lately which is I think what spurred this post.
I've been trying to rationalize defection as something inevitable and not just collusion. If it can be mathematically modeled then it's easier to think about rationally.
Re:Minimizing Defection Might Be the Solution to the Tragedy...
by TomMckenny on Saturday August 03, 2019 @07:26PM
(#20603367)
I had always though the difference was an assertion of the speaker's values: HK protesters are cooperating to stand up for their rights vs The Phoebus cartel is colluding to the disadvantage of consumers.
But maybe there is an objective detectable difference, perhaps related to defection reluctance. It would be great if there is some additional force at play that differentiates between them.
But at the same time, theories around a healthy market _require_ defection in order to "guarantee" competition. So in its rawest form, we have an economic system that requires a system that is known to produce some bad outcomes (climate change) in order to avoid other bad outcomes (collusion). This poses large systemic challenge indeed.