News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China has started a grand experiment in AI education by dr_dshiv on Friday August 02, 2019 @11:43AM (#20593873)
One problem with AI in education is that it promotes magical thinking. That is, if you rationally understand what the AI is doing, it seems awfully simple. And then the disappointment comes: if it is simple and understandable, it isn't really AI.

That's why you see a race for obscurity -- lots of jargon to describe the complexity of the system.

In reality, good educational software is about good design, good goal alignment, good assessments, good sequencing, good intervention material -- it's all based on classic instructional design, not a superior algorithm. Has the software been set up to support data driven continuous improvement? That is more important than an algorithm.

Re:China has started a grand experiment in AI education by scottlegrand2 on Friday August 02, 2019 @01:22PM (#20594763)
I'm going to disagree here. I have enough understanding of AI to have built a deep learning framework from first principles. That deep learning framework makes a pile of money for Amazon to this day.

That I know how it works because I wrote the thing doesn't take away from the miracle that it makes that kind of money for doing complicated but not all that complicated stuff.

When I look at generative adversarial networks and the recent attention-based language models I am similarly amazed at what they can do.

But I am also 100% aware of their limitations and I think the hype that they are near-term AGI technology is the real magical thinking.