News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple suspends Siri response grading in response to priva... by tialaramex on Friday August 02, 2019 @11:29AM (#20593747)
Counterpoint:

Google's actual smartphone line (Pixel) ships with passive song recognition, default disabled. I enabled it because I was curious and it sips so little power that I left it on, but to function it has to be listening to the audio all the time so that it can say to itself "Hey, that is Sabotage by the Beastie Boys".

It doesn't use the network, or the screen (unless you power the screen on to find out what you're listening to) but it passively remembers every recognisable song it heard, essentially forever. So that means it is _listening_ it just doesn't tell anybody about it.

Re:Apple suspends Siri response grading in response to priva... by jerf on Friday August 02, 2019 @04:10PM (#20596170)
That's part of why I left my caveat in there about the future. We've had chips to detect wakeup words for a while now. From what I know about song detection, that's likely to be doing yet more stuff, but still nowhere near enough for full voice transcription yet. But it is only a matter of time before your phone can be doing full voice transcription, with good guesses as to who the speaker is, full time. Squirting a full day's transcript of your speech up would be very easy to hide in all the chatter a phone already has, and squirting up just selected "suspicious" speech could easily be hidden in just the metadata network traffic of a phone.

We have not historically been there, which informs people's about cell phones, and we are not quite there yet. 4 or 5 years maybe.

(Although I have some interesting thoughts on how to deal with that. It would be fun to take one of these "transcribing phones" into a movie theatre, then fire the MPAA at Google for copyright infringement.)

Re:Apple suspends Siri response grading in response to priva... by cameronbrown on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:53PM (#20598349)
Isn't a transcript transformative content and therefore fair use? There are still hundreds of variations for every piece of content.
Re:Apple suspends Siri response grading in response to priva... by jerf on Monday August 05, 2019 @10:17AM (#20614387)
I wouldn't think so. It's basically the script of the movie, minus the stage directions, and I don't think the MPAA is going to agree that's not copyrightable. There's no "transformation" there in the copyright sense that I can see, it's just a copy.
Re:Apple suspends Siri response grading in response to priva... by andromeduck on Friday August 02, 2019 @04:45PM (#20596494)
Doesn't your phone have to be awake a few seconds for that?
Re:Apple suspends Siri response grading in response to priva... by tialaramex on Saturday August 03, 2019 @03:57AM (#20599201)
What does "awake" mean here? If you mean do I need to explicitly wake it, then definitely no, to test this I just left it on a desk while I played Pulp's "Do you remember the first time?" and read a magazine, after a few minutes I'd read several pages and the song had stopped, I opened the phone and it told me I had listened to "Do you remember the first time?" by Pulp six minutes ago.

Does it in some sense "wake up" to do this? Yes, I assume so.