News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China has started a grand experiment in AI education by mistrial9 on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:51AM (#20593412)
anecdote, if you will.. in a major University setting, for natural sciences, a mixed-level study-group is listening to a presentation on a model of a forested ecosystem using remote sensing and "AI", though the emphasis was on ML with certain inputs. An American with a liberal-arts background and good CS training, asks "in this model, how can we find the limits of the validity of these assumptions. A real world is more complex than what is being modeled, so how can we describe that and find 'blind-spots' in the work here" .. Meanwhile, a serious student who may have been born in China, asks "how can the model results be cross-checked to eliminate human bias in the result interpretation?"

Now this same exchange could have happened between any two students with the basic alignments of "objective science" versus "natural sciences", but it did seem telling of a certain pure-science tilt on the part of the student from China. To push that further, one could say that the "objective science" angle lacked a certain "intellectual humility" in the inquiry, with an emphasis on the correctness of the machine results, and an assumption that better math will produce "winning" output. No real evidence, but that was an impression at that moment.

Re:China has started a grand experiment in AI education by ckris on Friday August 02, 2019 @12:20PM (#20594210)
I think it has more to do with that China's strength at the moment is being utilitarian. Their working theory is to increase capacity. That is why they are build a lot of high speed rail, cities and power plants. While in the West we talk about tweaking cars to being self-driving or interest rates in the mortgage market. Because we don't really have that urgency to do things at scale tomorrow.
Re:China has started a grand experiment in AI education by arethuza on Friday August 02, 2019 @11:12AM (#20593570)
Out of interest, what do you mean by the difference between "objective science" and "natural sciences" in this context? Is it the "formal science" vs "natural science" distinction (i.e. pretty much maths vs everything else).