News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube faces creator backlash by nickjj on Friday August 02, 2019 @06:48AM (#20591967)
Some of those are pretty ridiculous expectations of any content creator.

Scrub the audio? I don't think he's going to go in there and literally separate and remove the song's frequency from his voice which are interweaved together. Something like that takes a tremendous amount of knowledge and time and always comes out sounding bad because any time you remove shared frequencies it'll make your voice sound very choppy and robotic (I know because I've done things like this). His job would slowly become being an audio engineer instead of a traveler.

Overlaid a royalty free musical work to replace the copyrighted one? Not possible, his voice and background audio is on the same track. To do that would essentially mean muting the entire track. This is the easiest option and often what he does. He just cuts it or mutes it, both of which makes his video content worse.

Asked the market vendor to turn the radio off? He often does this in closed stores where he plans to spend a bit of time in, but it's unrealistic to expect anyone to do this in an open outdoor market with ~200 vendors spread around everywhere for 1,000 feet in every direction. You're asking to basically shut down the whole market and control every audio source while you walk around. Not happening for a regular person.

Waited until the radio played a work that was not copyrighted? Not possible due to the above reason but this is also a little more unreasonable because there's no reasonable chance a regular person will be able to determine which songs are copyright and which are not, especially not in another country where they don't even know what song is playing. Also by the time he researches the song (assuming he somehow figured out how to even determine if it's copyright or not), chances are a different song would be playing and now he's stuck in a research loop for the rest of his life, or ends up in an another infinite loop waiting for a copyright free song.

Re:YouTube faces creator backlash by dijksterhuis on Friday August 02, 2019 @05:48PM (#20596919)
What about overdubbing? That’s the trick the majority of the industry uses.

...

> Asked the market vendor to turn the radio off?

> Not happening for a regular person.

And here were get to the crux of the matter.

I defer you to Charlie Brooker’s excellent video on “how much making one episode of a TV show costs”... skip to 5:05 for the section on clearance.

https://youtu.be/LbrmaeiZ4RE

All this stuff I’ve talked about is looked at by teams of people in media companies because they have to exist within the scope of the the law.

And that’s the issue you seem to have. It’s unreasonable to expect one person to do 20 extra jobs.

Yes it is. Which is why media companies hire 100s of people. Because they have to comply with the law.

Just because this is one person doesn’t mean he is outside the scope of the law. He doesn’t get any special treatment for being an individual. He’s got to suck it up like the rest of us.

Re:YouTube faces creator backlash by nickjj on Sunday August 04, 2019 @05:39PM (#20609386)
He sometimes overdubs it while saying he has to mute the original audio due to record labels.

That video seems like an advertisement to try and convince people not to record anything unless they are a TV station.

I'm happy we live in a day where someone like Harald can just point a camera around a place while talking and it ends up being more entertaining (to me at least) than anything running on TV.