News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by tptacek on Saturday January 01, 2011 @07:27PM (#2058945)
There are tens of great arguments you could have made against deletionism, why make a bullshit one? You know it's not about the disk space --- though presumably not all of the 16 people who modded you up know that as well.
Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by alextgordon on Saturday January 01, 2011 @08:00PM (#2059014)
You have captured the spirit of deletionism perfectly. There is nothing wrong with the comment. Quite the opposite: it was witty, hence the upvotes and it's position at the top of the page.

Deletionists feel they can approach perfection by mechanically removing content according to some standard, even when readers are finding it useful or enjoyable.

Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by tptacek on Saturday January 01, 2011 @08:02PM (#2059019)
One person's wit is another person's snark. On HN, either is fine if accompanied by content. Stavros' comment not only didn't have content, it had anti- content; WP's notability requirements are not a space-saving mechanism (surely they could save more space by getting rid one of of the several tens of thousands of War and Peace's worth of words in the Wikipedia: namespace.)

The (most commonly expressed) logic behind deletionism is that WP occupies a privileged place on the web and thus the onus is on the project to have content be verifiable, so that people can't stuff totally bogus topics at the tops of Google searches. The project can't verify content for non-notable subjects.

Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by philwelch on Saturday January 01, 2011 @08:39PM (#2059103)
The project can't verify content for non-notable subjects.

If that was the case, there would be no need for notability policy, merely the current verifiability standards. Unfortunately, there are many verifiable subjects of legitimate interest to people (startups, English Premier League reserve goalkeepers, fashion models who have only appeared on six magazine covers in their career, Iranian power plants) that deletionists want Wikipedia to forget about entirely because they aren't "notable".

Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by tptacek on Saturday January 01, 2011 @08:51PM (#2059124)
WP people don't want the encyclopedia to "forget about" those topics; they are bickering about whether they deserve entire pages to themselves.

... which again gives lie to the idea that the issue is "disk space".

I'm not trying to get sucked into this "deletionism" vs "inclusionism" argument, since those labels suck all the oxygen out of the discussion ("what, you're siding with people who think _why doesn't belong in WP?" --- of course not.) I'm just pointing out how bankrupt the original comment was.

Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by philwelch on Saturday January 01, 2011 @10:17PM (#2059280)
Virtually no deletion arguments conclude with a merge, though. Typically the information is completely lost, no matter how well cited it is. Which makes the verifiability argument bankrupt as well, at least as a defense of what actually happens on Wikipedia.

If the verifiability argument were sufficient, the notability policies would all be scrapped and deletion policy would round down to "delete articles which don't have any verifiable statements in them, merge articles which are less than two or three full paragraphs long". Which, incidentally, was more or less the radical inclusionist platform back when I wasted time on Wikipedia.

Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by tptacek on Sunday January 02, 2011 @02:51PM (#2060823)
Wikipedia is broken in a lot of ways.

I wrote a big long comment about a year and a half ago where I supposed that the problems probably boil down to "editing as sport" and "status seeking quests for adminship". Both lead to situations where editing decisions are made in a slipshod fashion and then defended to the death to avoid losing points in RfA's.

Deletionism is not one of the things that is broken about Wikipedia. Deletionism makes absolute sense. Wikipedia owns the Google SERPs, there is tremendous incentive to paste up bullshit articles for profit, and the sheer volume of crap --- take this from someone who spent 4 months patrolling AfD --- is staggering. The "pure" deletionist ideology is harsh, but it ultimately serves the greater good of the project.

In every one of these debates, I see people lose sight of the fundamental point of Wikipedia. It is not, as many people believe, a repository of all human knowledge. It's an encyclopedia. The point is not to have all possible articles. In fact, that's the opposite of the point. The point is to have only good articles, using nothing but volunteer work.

I too am done wasting time on Wikipedia, and I'm pretty grossed out by what happens when you look under the rock that is the Wikipedia: namespace. But I respect the project itself. It is tremendously, staggeringly successful. It is clearly doing something right.

Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by andywood on Sunday January 02, 2011 @03:47PM (#2060978)
But for several years, up until, oh ~2005 or so, Wikipedia was on the path to becoming the repository of all human knowledge. Many people, including myself, found that to be extremely valuable, and exciting.

Why don't we get to say that the fundamental point of Wikipedia is to be an aspiring repository of all human knowledge? Asserting that the reason for these policies is that it's [merely] an encyclopedia [more or less in the traditional sense] is self-fulfilling rhetoric. You say "the point is X" but I say "the point was Y, and could have continued to be if certain people didn't establish turf and assert control."

From my point of view, Wikipedia was on the way to being something much more than what it is now, and value was lost.

Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by tptacek on Sunday January 02, 2011 @03:59PM (#2061009)
When was that ever the stated goal of Wikipedia? Cite a source?
Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by philwelch on Sunday January 02, 2011 @05:38PM (#2061347)
"Imagine a world in which every single person on the planet is given free access to the sum of all human knowledge. That's what we're doing." --Jimbo Wales, Slashdot interview, 2004

http://interviews.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=04/07/28/13512...

Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by ghshephard on Saturday January 01, 2011 @09:44PM (#2059225)
I'm guessing at _least_ 15 out of those 16 people knew that deletionism has nothing to do with the cost of disk space. It was more a vote of frustration over the overreaching that occurs when seminal figures like _why have their Wikipedia Page deleted. There are _shades_ of notability, and I agree that someone has to make a call:

  Not:     o How many times have I sneezed today. 
  Barely:  o The Ties of my Local Anchorman
  Notable: o Pokemon Characters, _why, Canada
 
Unfortunately, the deletionists have moved from "Not" to "Barely" and in some cases have started yanking out very clearly notable pages. The upvote, above, is, I suspect, people expressing that frustration.
Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by ghaff on Sunday January 02, 2011 @10:16AM (#2060124)
Notability is a really tough concept in the context of Wikipedia for a couple of reasons.

The first is that notability is in no small part a function of scale. Many things that would not make the cut in a global, space-limited encyclopedia are nevertheless in Wikipedia (properly) because they're notable to some niche of contributors/readers. But once you start having articles about some episode of a 1980s TV show, how can you, in good conscience, say that an article about a selectman in a small town or an athlete at a small college isn't also notable?

And verifiability gets interesting in this context. Effectively, verifiability puts disproportionate weight on verifiability through traditional media. Thus, presumably, school newspapers and the like would be considered an indication that something is indeed notable.

Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by tptacek on Sunday January 02, 2011 @02:54PM (#2060829)
Because the selectman wasn't written about in a reliable secondary source, and the TV show was.

What, you say, the selectman appeared in a newspaper article? Congratulations: you're done. Cite it. The article will stick. Someone will inevitably try to delete it; you'll point to the sourcing at the bottom of the article, and you'll win the AfD.

It's really not complicated.

It is also NOT ABOUT "FAIR". Notability and verifiability aren't value judgements about subjects. They are judgements about the COMPATIBILITY of subjects with Wikipedia.

Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by tptacek on Saturday January 01, 2011 @09:51PM (#2059234)
Your anti-deletionism argument is insufficiently doctrinaire: it acknowledges that there may exist some true statements that might merit deletion from Wikipedia. Many inclusionists find that idea repellant.

For whatever it's worth: _why has a page. Nobody ever tried to delete Canada. Pokemon characters have pages because they are easily verified.

Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by celoyd on Saturday January 01, 2011 @10:20PM (#2059286)
Your anti-deletionism argument is insufficiently doctrinaire

Having just appreciated your criticism of a sarcastic and unhelpful comment, I hope you’re not turning to easy point-scoring yourself.

Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by tptacek on Sunday January 02, 2011 @03:04PM (#2060855)
I'm flattered that you think I'm taking a high road here, but I'm really just irritated at the fact that the comment was content-free snark.
Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by StavrosK on Sunday January 02, 2011 @01:38AM (#2059576)
You have hit my motives for the comment on the head, thank you for the elaboration for those who might mistake my intent.
Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by kolmogorovcmplx on Sunday January 02, 2011 @04:40PM (#2061143)
This continuous lowering of the "delete or not" bar should be pretty obvious to anybody who has followed Wikipedia for some time.

I used to be of the opinion that it was justified, but has realised lately that it has become a tool for political censorship. Some of the editing cliques have become very adept at suppressing unwanted views with dubious, but to many persuasive, application of the verifiability and notability policies.

Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by tptacek on Sunday January 02, 2011 @05:25PM (#2061308)
It should be very, very easy for you to produce a URL illustrating this phenomenon for those of us who are skeptical of it.
Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by kolmogorovcmplx on Sunday January 02, 2011 @05:52PM (#2061374)
I have seen this happen on several subjects, but as it has been over a year since I actively participated and followed Wikipedia internals, I cannot immediately give you a particular example.

My observation of this abuse of policy has been as a bystander by the way. I've never actively edited any articles on these subjects.

Typical subjects where there most certainly are well organized and ideologically motivated editorial cliques include US foreign policy, anything to do with Israel, Turkey and its history, anything relating to Islam etc.

Abuse of the notability policy is just one, but very effective, tool for censoring and controlling the content though.

Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by StavrosK on Sunday January 02, 2011 @02:08PM (#2060719)
I was being intentionally absurd because I wanted to highlight that deletionist policy is not very relevant. Sure, you don't want every article about what I ate today, but well-written articles about obscure subjects don't hurt anything, why should they be deleted?
Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by tptacek on Sunday January 02, 2011 @02:27PM (#2060766)
That first sentence doesn't even make sense: the whole debate over deletionism vs. inclusionism isn't even relevant to this article. You're like the guy who can't stop from commenting about Wikileaks on Amazon stories. Please, stop.
Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by StavrosK on Sunday January 02, 2011 @02:39PM (#2060794)
On the contrary, I think the debate over the issues of a service that is soliciting donations from us is of direct relevance.
Re:Wikipedia Raises $16 Million to Remain Ad-Free by tptacek on Sunday January 02, 2011 @04:04PM (#2061033)
You didn't debate issues of any service. You tried to score points with a snarky and ultimately false comment.

(Also, apropos nothing, but because I just looked up who you are: that CRAM-MD5 proposal on your website is terribly broken; please don't recommend it to people.)