News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Known packings of equal circles in a circle by robocat on Thursday August 01, 2019 @05:34PM (#20588588)
Orange is three circles all touching each other (hexagonal close pack), or two circles touching each other and the outside (I have reedited this sentence for clarity).

Magenta is unconstrained.

Blue is special case that can only exist for N=2.

The rest are yellow.

The number of lines in the middle show the number of touchs (constraints, 0 to 6).

Not sure how multiple solutions are shown (e.g. N=6 has two solutions).

Re:Known packings of equal circles in a circle by JonathonW on Thursday August 01, 2019 @06:32PM (#20588992)
Blue isn't only for N=2; it starts showing up again at N=104.

It appears that circles are colored blue if their number of contacts (with either other circles or the outside) is equal to 1 or 2. They're magenta if their number of contacts is zero.

I'm not sure what the distinction between orange and yellow is-- it doesn't seem to be strictly number of contacts, because I can see cases where both orange and yellow have four contacts.

Re:Known packings of equal circles in a circle by robocat on Thursday August 01, 2019 @07:06PM (#20589199)
Reread my answer for orange, I'm sure it is correct. To say it a different way: a circle X is coloured orange if X is touching a circle Y, and both X and Y also touch circle Z. Y and Z can either be small circles or the main outer circle.

The colours are about constraints. Orange is a locked constraint between 3 circles (inner and outer included).

If you think about it, N=2 is the only solution that the circles are constrained to touch in two places (and N=1 is weird because it touches in infinite places).

At N=104, the blue circles are surely a drawing fault, they are actually unconstrained and should be magenta. Shown by fact that those blue circles have a dot in the middle (not touching), but a neighbour circle has a line pointing to the blue circle (touching), which is contradictory.

Re:Known packings of equal circles in a circle by showdead on Friday August 02, 2019 @11:23AM (#20593691)
For N=104, if you look at the PDF and zoom in, you can see the blue circles have a line rather than a dot. Admittedly, it is hard to see why the blue circles do not have enough freedom to move slightly away and become magenta (particularly the one on N=108).