To me, there is no ethical issue here. It's a website with information about stuff. Do I need information about said stuff? Nope. But apparently someone does.
efreedom, mahalo — they have tons of information and are almost pure pollution.
Is this really more "pollution" than people's blogs about how they went drinking with their friends last night?
That makes sense.
This type of practice is nothing new, and it's much closer to efreedom and mahalo than it is to some guy writing about his new year's eve party on blogger.
Again, his research shows no evidence that people are looking for anything other than the login page for Facebook, which they are finding easily via Google if they don't know how do use the address bar.
Most people conflate "the internet" with what Google shows us when we search for things. The bigger issue is that an exact match keyword domain ranks ridiculously well in Google and yet they know that and aren't changing anything. $9 stands between you and a top 10 ranking for the majority of low competition keywords.