News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Breaking a WoW addiction by klipt on Saturday January 01, 2011 @04:18PM (#2058477)
> What about all the dead people who come back to life thanks to medical intervention?

Then they weren't really dead.

> This is an outdated perspective. Loads of people now living were once dead.

Maybe if you're using an outdated definition of death. By death I mean brain death, from which there is no recovery by definition ("the irreversible end of all brain activity").

The cessation of breathing etc. is no longer a useful definition of "death" precisely because of the "coming back to life" you describe:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death#Problems_of_definition

> Dead things become alive through natural processes. But to be alive you first have to be dead.

The dead things are not "you" in any useful sense of the word. Yes I know it's the same atoms, but "you" are not just your atoms. "You" are an emergent pattern of thoughts and memories, which cannot begin to emerge until your brain develops.

Sure, you can take the cosmological approach that we are all connected, all things are one etc., but in practice, once your definition of "you" no longer distinguishes "you" from "not you", it's no longer a useful word.

> Your superset theorem of meaning is probably a rationalization of some deep emotional bias that has roots in your genes and early childhood environment.

Sure, I clearly stated it was just my opinion. All opinions have roots in genes and experiences. But the experience of arguing with you has thus far failed to change my opinion, it's merely persuaded me that you use very different definitions for words than I do ;)

Re:Breaking a WoW addiction by forensic on Monday January 03, 2011 @08:06PM (#2065380)
There are operational definitions of death and then there are more philosophical ones.

My point is simply that death itself can hold just as much meaning as life because meaning is deeply subjective. No scientific fact changes this.

Tomorrow we may discover a way to raise the dead - to turn the people you currently define as irreversibly brain impaired into... living humans.

The ancients used to refer to the breathe of life, now you have to refer to a very controversial operational definition.

I contend that this has little effect on the subjective human experience of meaning and whether or not the human emotions find meaning in death.