When I try to wake up without enough sleep it just feels horrible. Sort of headache/stomach ache combo. I can set an alarm and force myself to wake up early if I need to, but I end up paying for it later and my body demands extra sleep to make up for it.
I get amazing bursts of creativity and clarity when I'm in an energetic phase - so I guess I'd be devastated if I lost that high energy. But a lot of the time there is just stuff to get done so if I had control over whether I have 8hrs or 10hrs then that would be ideal.
The reason 10vs7 is way worse than 8vs5 is that it kills my social life or side-project time. If I go to a party and only get back at mighnight, then I'm screwed if I want to get to work before 11am the next day. If I force myself to wake up at 8am, I can expect to be asleep at 6pm after work the following day.
What happens if you go to sleep at 7:30pm and set an alarm for 9:00pm?
Would you like it better if you got only 7-8 hours of sleep but weren't as energetic during your waking hours?
If you were sleeping only 8 hours and felt great, would you feel cheated if everyone around you only slept for 5 hours?
All of this depends on you, and what works for you. You may have to experiment.