For one, they are bringing up a stack that's quite different from the one usually found on smartphones, which sounds quite costly.
From the security point of view, I am not sure it would be less secure on the sw side, but it would be less open. On the hw side, they have kill switches, isolated the firmware on ROM chips (RYF-compliant), and have a pretty strict security-first approach.
Unfortunately that places it out of reach for me, financially-speaking. I'll continue with postmarketos, and keep an eye on the pinephone.
Price = cost of goods sold (hardware) + (profit + development overhead + marketing + ...) / number of units sold
So, yes, if they didn’t bother spending r&d resources on security, they could charge less.
Also, the marginal price of security is much higher than with the big two, since the number of units sold is smaller.
I wish them well, but they picked a tough fight.
I think they're going to discover that a lot of people say they want security but when push comes to shove when they're buying a phone they first and foremost want a good phone. If you were really bothered about security and privacy on a phone you'd just use tracking blockers, a disposable (google) account, not log into facebook, turn off location, use tor, or existing encrypted chat software to talk to other people who are also using disposable (ie not their main email accounts to sign up to google) accounts etc. But do all this on a regular phone. I'd always been concerned about timely security updates, software that's been written by people with no experience with security and who have no reputation to damage by cutting corners.
How does that affect the price tag? Would it be less secure if they charged less?