Re:Beijing Presses Hong Kong Government to Quell Unrest
by yorwba on Monday July 29, 2019 @04:08PM
(#20558799)
> I'm surprised by that language as it seems to be targeted at a Western, potentially even Coastal US, audience.
Not at all. If a government institution or company in China makes an unpopular decision that leads to large protests, the government will usually issue a statement that condemns the protests as "riots", but simultaneously promises changes that basically amount to fulfilling the protester's demands, i.e. they do some "summary and reflection".
The government's power isn't threatened by the occasional protest succeeding, but by those protests growing in scale, either by making more demands or by inspiring similar movements in other parts of China. That's why they censor all news about ongoing protests, arrest any leaders they can identify and send in riot police to stop the protesters reaching any place where they can get more attention. But those measures aren't effective at stopping a protest that has already started, they can only prevent it from spreading. In the end, some actual change is necessary to convince protesters that there's no need to keep protesting and they can go home.
So basically the central government is criticizing the Hong Kong government for not acquiescing to the demands quickly enough and letting the protests grow to this scale, where they can't be kept out of the news anymore.
Not at all. If a government institution or company in China makes an unpopular decision that leads to large protests, the government will usually issue a statement that condemns the protests as "riots", but simultaneously promises changes that basically amount to fulfilling the protester's demands, i.e. they do some "summary and reflection".
The government's power isn't threatened by the occasional protest succeeding, but by those protests growing in scale, either by making more demands or by inspiring similar movements in other parts of China. That's why they censor all news about ongoing protests, arrest any leaders they can identify and send in riot police to stop the protesters reaching any place where they can get more attention. But those measures aren't effective at stopping a protest that has already started, they can only prevent it from spreading. In the end, some actual change is necessary to convince protesters that there's no need to keep protesting and they can go home.
So basically the central government is criticizing the Hong Kong government for not acquiescing to the demands quickly enough and letting the protests grow to this scale, where they can't be kept out of the news anymore.