News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open source all-iron battery for renewable energy storage by kragen on Saturday July 27, 2019 @10:22AM (#20542153)
Certainly iron is the metal to look at if you're going for the lowest cost, but the results so far are not inspiring.

There are about nine orders of magnitude in between these results and utility-scale energy storage, but it doesn't seem like that's what they're aiming for—the existing flow batteries they mention in the paper would be a better fit. They seem to be aiming at home applications, but they are seven orders of magnitude away from even the “tens of kilowatts” they cite in their abstract as typical for such applications.

However, both the negative results they mention in passing and the positive ones are major contributions to the progress of such low-cost battery designs.

Iron costs around US$0.03 per kg, while lithium is more like US$300 and nickel is US$30. In the intervening 3 orders of magnitude, cheaper than nickel but not as cheap as iron, are aluminum, antimony, arsenic, cadmium, carbon, cerium, chromium, copper, lead, manganese, samarium, silicon, tin, titanium, vanadium, and zinc.

Some of these are unpromising precisely because they are too electronegative; zinc, as they said, cannot be reduced electrolytically in water; the same problem applies to titanium, aluminum, and carbon—but maybe a different electrolyte could solve that problem. Others, like lead, are already in common use for batteries.

Chromium, titanium dioxide, vanadium, tin and tin oxide, copper, manganese and its oxides, cerium, samarium, and of course lead seem like plausible candidates. Indeed at least zinc-cerium batteries exist.

Re:Open source all-iron battery for renewable energy storage by tim333 on Saturday July 27, 2019 @10:54AM (#20542277)
I'm not sure their materials even sound all that cheap. From the article

"The total cost of materials is $0.1 per watt-hour"

Or presumably $100/kWh

On the other hand with Zinc Air "our fundamental raw material cost of zinc is just $2-$3/KWh." from https://www.altenergymag.com/article/2019/03/zinc-air-batter... talking about NantEnergy's rechargables.

Re:Open source all-iron battery for renewable energy storage by maxerickson on Saturday July 27, 2019 @11:20AM (#20542397)
Yeah, the interesting comparison is the energy storage per dollar, not the cost of the raw materials.
Re:Open source all-iron battery for renewable energy storage by tim333 on Saturday July 27, 2019 @12:19PM (#20542684)
Indeed. Nant have been talking $100/kWh all in which is cheap but I think that's projected rather than that you can actually buy them for anything like that. Though the material cost is interesting as a potential end point if you got super automated production. A problem with Vanadium flow for example is that the materials are like 60% of the cost of the battery so it's hard to drop much. With LiCo the materials are quite a big % of the battery cost though these things vary with time and may drop. I think Telsa are reducing the amount of Cobalt used dramatically for example https://qnovo.com/82-the-cost-components-of-a-battery/
Re:Open source all-iron battery for renewable energy storage by maxerickson on Saturday July 27, 2019 @12:45PM (#20542807)
Sodium ion batteries that don't use much in the way of exotic materials seem feasible. It's the sort of thing where someone has to be successfully selling them to prove that they are reasonably competitive though.
Re:Open source all-iron battery for renewable energy storage by kragen on Saturday July 27, 2019 @05:27PM (#20544290)
Pretty much all of the standard electrode potentials are like a volt or two. You aren't going to find a room-temperature molecular chemistry that gives you 10 or 100 electron volts of energy per atom. Lithium is pretty much the extreme there.
Re:Open source all-iron battery for renewable energy storage by pfdietz on Saturday July 27, 2019 @01:50PM (#20543151)
The cost of the raw materials is more interesting with flow batteries, where you can imagine adding big tanks containing the electrolytes without adding more cells.
Re:Open source all-iron battery for renewable energy storage by maxerickson on Saturday July 27, 2019 @02:23PM (#20543347)
It still comes down to the cost per unit of energy stored. If the electrolyte is a mediocre storage medium with low costs, it may not be competitive with an excellent storage medium with moderate costs, even after increased manufacturing costs.
Re:Open source all-iron battery for renewable energy storage by pfdietz on Saturday July 27, 2019 @01:48PM (#20543144)
Sulfur-based flow batteries are supposed to be very cheap in principle, with the active chemicals costing around $1/kWh. Of course all these lab technologies face a perilous journey to the market.

https://spectrum.ieee.org/energywise/energy/renewables/new-s...

Re:Open source all-iron battery for renewable energy storage by kragen on Sunday July 28, 2019 @12:36AM (#20545854)
> zinc, as they said, cannot be reduced electrolytically in water;

Actually this is total bullshit. You can totally electroplate zinc. Electroplating just about started with zinc. That's why zinc plating is called “galvanizing”, even if nowadays hot-dip plating is a more common way to “galvanize” metal. Either I misunderstood the article or it's wrong. (I'd bet on the first, though.)