News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by Skinney on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @04:35AM (#20513273)
The commas and dots are operators, not syntax.

one, two, three.

Is essentially compiled down to:

if (one && two && three) { return three; }

Whereas

one, two, three;

one, four.

compiles down to:

if (one && two && three) { return three; } else if (one && four) { return four; }

So yeah, it's not syntax.

, === &&

; === ||

. marks end of a condition, so } in C.

Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by pmontra on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @06:41AM (#20513833)
The script is

  import util.

  input_data(Tri) => 
    Lines = read_file_lines("triangle.txt"),
    Tri = new_array(Lines.length),
    I = 1,
    foreach(Line in Lines)
        Tri[I] = Line.split().map(to_integer).to_array(),
        I := I+1
    end.
In the mind of an imperative scripting developer those commas are (useless) semicolons.

I wrote a little Prolog some 30 years ago. Probably those commas and dots have the same function, logic and, as you write.

I understand that it's a core feature of the language, but its really awkward when using Picat imperatively. I've seen this dynamic of obeyibg to tradition in many languages. The vast majority of developers are used to imperative languages. If designers of functional, logic, etc languages want to hijack those developers to their own language they could try to be creative and bold and give those developers a syntax their are familiar with.

Elixir has a Ruby like syntax to Erlang and had some success at onboarding Ruby developers. But it wasn't bold. Example: they didn't have courage to turn GenServer into a Class with a CPU. It's still a bag of functions, partly called by clients, partly called by the server, with method names (if it was a class) hidden in arguments and explicit state management.

The Reia language was a bolder attempt but unfortunately its designer liked Elixir and killed his project. My guess: there would be many more Reia developers than Elixir ones by now.

http://reia-lang.org/

Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by pessimizer on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @11:14AM (#20516057)
The idea that typing commas is far more difficult than typing semicolons is common, but bizarre. I feel like you're using a lot of words here to rationalize being accustomed to semicolons or significant whitespace as a logical preference rather than an aesthetic one. Consider commas somewhere between a minimalist and maximalist aesthetic (" " < "," < ";"), but one that values consistency.
Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by YeGoblynQueenne on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @11:57AM (#20516521)
I changed all the commas to "and"'s" and the dots to ";"'s (except in a.b statements):

  import util;

  input_data(Tri) => 
    Lines = read_file_lines("triangle.txt") and 
    Tri = new_array(Lines.length) and 
    I = 1 and 
    foreach(Line in Lines)
        Tri[I] = Line.split().map(to_integer).to_array() and 
        I := I+1
    end;

Is that better?
Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by pmontra on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @06:04PM (#20520377)
No. My point is that language designers should try to implement different paradigms with mainstream syntax. This if they are interested in making their languages mainstream, which might not be their goal.

The script should do without the ands, the commas and the colons. The end of line should be the and, or what the language understands to be the end of a statement.

By the way, the dot or the semicolon after the end look really redundant.

Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by YeGoblynQueenne on Thursday July 25, 2019 @11:00AM (#20525944)
>> The end of line should be the and, or what the language understands to be the end of a statement.

The problem with that is that the "," is there not to separate statements ("literals") but to declare a relation between them, specifically, conjunction.

Conjunction is one relation that you may way to declare between literals. There is also disjunction and implication. So you do need something to separate "A and B" from "A or B" and "A if B".

You say- "use whitespace for the and". OK. But then, what about the "or" and the "if"? And if we use special symbols for the "or" and the "if" then what's the point of not using one for the "and" also?

As to "block" delimiters, like "." or ";" etc. As far as I can tell the only languages that do not have "block" delimiters are the kind you can find on https://esolangs.org/wiki/, and that is for reasons of a) readability, actually and b) convenience in compiler writing.

Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by didibus on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @11:04AM (#20515947)
I think most designers of alternative paradigm languages also prefer the alternative syntaxes.
Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by pmontra on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @05:58PM (#20520290)
You're probably right, and those languages risk staying alternative forever.
Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by dkersten on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @06:22AM (#20513747)
The issue I see is that a . and a , are tiny little marks on the screen that are super easy to miss and, at a glance, the . , ; all can look the same. Maybe with practice you can spot the differences easier, but certainly as a newcomer to the language its a lot of extra cognitive load. && and || at least are super obvious.
Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by Skinney on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @06:53AM (#20513889)
I don't write Picat, but when I write Prolog the color scheme for Emacs gives those operators a bright color so they stand out.
Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by dkersten on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @07:08AM (#20513952)
Right. As someone who uses raindbow parentheses, I should have immediately thought that it would be solved by the editor. Still, I don't like if readability relies on the editor too much, since you often want to paste or read code elsewhere (on HN, stackoverflow, github, random websites, etc) that may not know about your non-mainstream language.
Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by masukomi on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @03:55PM (#20519013)
if making your editor compensate for the language syntax is the only way to make the language syntax easily readable then the language designer has failed.
Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by YeGoblynQueenne on Thursday July 25, 2019 @10:36AM (#20525716)
The comma and dot are natural ways to separate and end statements in natural language. Why are they a problem in a programming language, where you have to be extremely careful about your syntax anyway?
Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by dkersten on Thursday July 25, 2019 @06:02PM (#20530237)
I think there's two reasons:

First, its a trend. Other languages have trained us to not see them so much (as pard68 said), to put much more weight on other things. Its not complete though, many programming languages do use them: to separate elements in a list, to separate parameters, as method.calls, and in numbers 1.0, so that's probably a very minor reason over all.

Second, programming languages are very symbol heavy: we use all kinds of operators and special->symbols and (various [brackets]), it just kinda drowns out small symbols that are at the bottom of the line like a , or . and they're just not as obvious as keywords or ink-heavy symbols.

But overall, I guess I'm just not used to seeing them in that context and I'd get over it really quickly, just like I very quickly got over Python's significant whitespace or Lisps parentheses. It seems like a big deal until one day suddenly its not anymore.

Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by YeGoblynQueenne on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @12:00PM (#20516561)
And the compiler gives a bright (red) color to their absence, also.

You do need the Swi-Prolog IDE for that though.

Re:Picat – a logic-based multi-paradigm programming language by pard68 on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @07:10AM (#20513965)
Especially when you are used to more or less filtering out '.', ',', and ';'.