I guess I didn't realize that I needed to explictly call out the existence of friendly, helpful, newb-friendly Lisp teachers on Paul Graham's Hacker News as implemented in Arc -- it is easy to forget that not everybody is steeped in the local culture -- but let me now be more explicit: There are plenty of people who are happy to help teach newbs all about higher-order programming by helping them implement their very own toy version of Lisp, and by taking joy in the results. Thank god for those people.
http://axisofeval.blogspot.com/2010/08/three-principles-of-l...
One of the author's projects is writing a lisp.
edit- actually it's right there at the top of the page on the right. Motivation: Lisp.
Yes, he has a project to build his own Lisp, because he doesn't like existing ones. That's a detractor.
http://axisofeval.blogspot.com/2010/07/c-40-industrial-respo...
In other words: CL sucks but all the other dynamic languages suck more. My semantics don't label that as "detraction" but yours may differ.
"What's more worrying is that all dynlangs, including the few acceptable ones, like Common Lisp and Factor, are starting to look horribly dated against C#. Seriously."
Don't measure a community by its detractors.
Further, people don't wonder why PHP is popular. Its popularity originated in ISP-friendliness, and has grown since then through network effects.
EDIT: People are still voting up the parent comment, so I probably wasn't clear enough: the parent comment is totally wrong, starting with the words "It's this". The attitude of someone who does not like Lisp is not even a single datapoint, much less evidence, as to how the Lisp community treats newbies.