News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Oatmeal (online cartoon) earns ~$1000/day by stcredzero on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @11:05AM (#2049076)
Depressing to me, because I find most of the content there to be, "clever only to people of pedestrian intelligence." Then again, perhaps this is just savvy marketing.
Re:The Oatmeal (online cartoon) earns ~$1000/day by presidentender on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @11:18AM (#2049131)
Stephen King, whose success is similarly depressing to some, mentions this specifically in 'On Writing.' His great gift, as he put it, is to entertain those of similar intellect to himself. Fortunately for him, he's on the top half of the fat part of the bell curve, so there are many such similar intellects to entertain. I am glad to be one.

While I find 'The Oatmeal' to be somewhat boring and trite, I don't begrudge those who like it their enjoyment, nor do I begrudge the author his income.

Re:The Oatmeal (online cartoon) earns ~$1000/day by stcredzero on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @01:16PM (#2049607)
Stephen King, whose success is similarly depressing to some, mentions this specifically in 'On Writing.' His great gift, as he put it, is to entertain those of similar intellect to himself.

I think this is an exercise in awareness, which would be of particular value to the HN crowd. Apple's products are often castigated because their construction/composition/stats go against the preferences of a part of the highly tech-savvy crowd. However, this criticism doesn't take into account the intended audience. There is something similar at work with Ruby and Ruby on Rails. Certain purists might find the language impure and the Rails DSL too focused on a particular way of doing things, but there is a large audience that really likes and benefits from using that software.

While I find 'The Oatmeal' to be somewhat boring and trite, I don't begrudge those who like it their enjoyment, nor do I begrudge the author his income.

Well said! (Better than I did.) I don't begrudge either of those. I also hope no one in this society [1] begrudges my right to express my opinion.

[1] - Deliberately ambiguous, as it's widely applicable.

Re:The Oatmeal (online cartoon) earns ~$1000/day by blacksmythe on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @01:31PM (#2049640)

  << nor do I begrudge the author his income
I don't think any of us begrudge the author his income. I imagine many people are looking at that and thinking what I am which is "why couldn't I do at least as well".

This is much unlike reading xkcd, where I know quite well that I couldn't do as well.

Re:The Oatmeal (online cartoon) earns ~$1000/day by code_duck on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @12:04PM (#2049325)
I suppose you're not allowed to express your opinion here without being penalized. Personally, I find this comic to be completely awful, and the drawings absolutely hideous - offensively stupid in a way that could not be exceeded even intentionally. But then, people defend Justin Bieber, too. We're not here to discuss that though.

The focus of the HN crowd is going to be on how he obtained his high level of (financial!) success. To me, it's yet another lesson that mediocrity and lack of talent are no barriers to success. Other factors such as persistence, marketing savvy, funding, connections and lack of any shame about self promotion (this guy practically spammed the hell out of Reddit and Digg 2008-2009) can take you very far.

Re:The Oatmeal (online cartoon) earns ~$1000/day by BrandonM on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @12:10PM (#2049353)
Another lesson is to avoid saying amazingly haughty things like, "clever only to people of pedestrian intelligence."

Metacommentary is annoying, but here goes. His comment was downvoted because it was demeaning without furthering the discussion much. I considered downvoting your comment because it insultingly misstates the reason for members' downvotes when the actual reason is pretty obvious; I actually voted up your comment (since it was down to -1) in spite of that and its defeatist tone because it still made an interesting point.

Re:The Oatmeal (online cartoon) earns ~$1000/day by natep on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @04:38PM (#2050259)
I see lots of discussion prompted by stcredzero's comment (11 replies, including this one and the 2 deleted ones). How again did it not further the discussion?
Re:The Oatmeal (online cartoon) earns ~$1000/day by stcredzero on Thursday December 30, 2010 @07:24AM (#2052021)
Another lesson is to avoid saying amazingly haughty things like, "clever only to people of pedestrian intelligence."

The lesson I've received, after sparking all this discussion, getting voted down, then back up again, is that it pays off in the end to be open and genuine.

[deleted]
[deleted]
Re:The Oatmeal (online cartoon) earns ~$1000/day by code_duck on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @12:32PM (#2049444)
This has to be the most useless line of comments I've see on HN in a long time.
Re:The Oatmeal (online cartoon) earns ~$1000/day by stcredzero on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @01:22PM (#2049624)
Actually, there's a very useful analogy and lesson for startup folks.
Re:The Oatmeal (online cartoon) earns ~$1000/day by megablast on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @05:36PM (#2050435)
I have a problem with people who seem to be so passionate about stuff they hate. You use the example of Justin Bieber, who my niece quite likes, but loads of people do not. I tend to ignore the things that have no effect on me, and I do not like. Other people feel the need to attack such things. They are the ones with the problem.

If you do not like something, why bother wasting your time commenting on it. Sure, if it is something that affects you, like your government or road rules, go ahead. If it is something you can ignore, then YOU are being the fool.

Re:The Oatmeal (online cartoon) earns ~$1000/day by code_duck on Thursday December 30, 2010 @06:15PM (#2053892)
I'm not concerned with Justin Bieber or Oatmeal specifically. Personally I'm interested in, and disappointed by, the phenomenon of people with no musical talent being successful musicians, and humorists with no discernible wit or drawing skill being successful comic artists. The problem is not the people who are successful - the problem is with the audience. To each their own, but you don't really like something like Justin Bieber as a musical taste. People think you like it because they have too little experience with real music, and it is marketed very heavily.
Re:The Oatmeal (online cartoon) earns ~$1000/day by BrandonM on Thursday December 30, 2010 @12:27AM (#2051342)
I agree with your "foolish" comment :)
Re:The Oatmeal (online cartoon) earns ~$1000/day by FlemishBeeCycle on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @03:00PM (#2049954)
While it may be "depressing", isn't it logically consistent with how the world appears to work?

One way to make a lot of money is to sell a lot of a product.

Most people are of "pedestrian" (average) intelligence; ergo, to sell a lot of product you must appeal to those of average intelligence.

As any industry grows you see this "regression towards the mean" - one only has to cock one's ear slightly to the side to hear the lamentation of readers, gamers and movie-buffs about how "everything has gone to the dogs".